In my daily work with lost wax casting, I have come to treat shrinkage cavities and shrinkage porosity as the most revealing defects of the entire process. They are not merely holes; they are records of how heat left the metal, how the shell absorbed that heat, how the gating system fed the solidifying part, and how the alloy itself contracted from the pouring temperature to room temperature. When I inspect a lost wax casting that has failed prematurely, I always begin by looking for shrinkage. The defect may appear as a rough, irregular cavity with visible dendritic branches, or as a fine network of porosity that is difficult to see without machining or nitric acid etching. In either case, the root cause is almost always the same: the last liquid to solidify did not receive enough feed metal.

The purpose of this article is to set out what I have learned about the formation, location, mechanism, causes, and prevention of shrinkage defects in lost wax casting. I will use tables and equations to summarize the key relationships, because I have found that production teams can act on them more quickly when they are expressed numerically. I will also describe a field case in which rare earth microalloying and process changes turned a short-lived lost wax casting into a component that exceeded its required service life by a wide margin.
Characteristics of Shrinkage Defects in Lost Wax Casting
In lost wax casting, the metal is poured into a hot ceramic shell. The shell has been preheated, and the metal is often superheated. As the metal cools, it passes through liquid contraction, solidification contraction, and solid contraction. The first two contractions are the ones that create shrinkage cavities and shrinkage porosity. When the last liquid pool cannot be fed, a concentrated cavity forms. When feeding is insufficient on a local scale, dispersed porosity forms among the dendrites.
I classify shrinkage defects in lost wax casting into three practical forms: external shrinkage, internal shrinkage, and corner shrinkage. External shrinkage breaks the surface and is visible. Internal shrinkage is enclosed within the casting and may only be found by radiography, sectioning, or machining. Corner shrinkage occurs at re-entrant angles where the local heat capacity is high and heat extraction is poor. The visual signature is similar in all three: a rough, irregular surface, sometimes with well-developed dendritic crystals. The difference is mainly location and accessibility.
| Defect form | Typical location in lost wax casting | Visual or inspection signature | Primary feeding problem |
|---|---|---|---|
| External shrinkage | Open surface of a hot spot or thick section | Visible cavity, rough walls, dendritic relief | Last liquid at surface cannot be fed |
| Internal shrinkage | Interior hot spot, thick section, isolated mass | Found by X-ray, sectioning, or machining; irregular void | Riser or gate freezes before interior |
| Corner shrinkage | Re-entrant angle, concave corner, junction of walls | Local cavity at the corner, often after machining | Poor local heat extraction and feed path |
I have learned not to judge a shrinkage defect only by its size. A small internal shrinkage cavity in a highly stressed lost wax casting can be more damaging than a larger external cavity that will be removed by machining. For this reason, the first question is always: where is the last point to solidify, and can the gating system feed it? If the answer is no, a shrinkage defect is likely.
Locations of Shrinkage Defects in Lost Wax Casting
Shrinkage cavities occur in regions that solidify last and cannot be fed. In lost wax casting, these regions are usually hot spots, thick walls, heavy flanges, bosses, and isolated masses. The exact location is also influenced by gate position, heat dissipation from different parts of the shell, the influence of the gating system on heat flow, and the relative position of parts on the same tree. When I arrange a lost wax casting tree, I know that each part shadows its neighbors and changes the local cooling rate. A hot spot that would be safe in a single-part layout may become a shrinkage location when several parts are clustered together.
Several methods can estimate the likely shrinkage location. I use them together rather than relying on one. First, I draw solidification isotherms. Second, I use the inscribed circle method to identify hot spots. Third, I section a sample casting and inspect it. Fourth, I use casting process simulation software to observe filling and solidification and to predict shrinkage cavities and porosity. The simulation is especially useful for lost wax casting because the shell preheat, shell thickness, and tree arrangement can be varied before cutting metal.
| Method | What I look for | Advantage in lost wax casting | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solidification isotherms | Regions that remain liquid after surrounding metal solidifies | Shows thermal gradients and feed paths | Needs accurate thermal data |
| Inscribed circles | Largest circles fitting local sections | Quick hot-spot identification | Approximate for complex shapes |
| Sectioning | Actual cavities and porosity | Direct evidence | Destructive and after the fact |
| Process simulation | Filling, solidification, shrinkage probability | Can be run before tooling | Requires validated properties |
From my experience, the most common shrinkage locations in lost wax casting are the following: a heavy section connected to a thin wall; a boss on a plate; a flange at the end of a tube; a junction where several walls meet; and the last-filled region of a mold cavity. I also pay attention to the gate contact. If the gate is too small, it freezes early and isolates the hot spot. If the gate is too large, it may remain liquid too long and create a shrinkage cavity at the gate-casting junction. The balance is delicate.
Mechanism of Shrinkage Cavity Formation in Lost Wax Casting
The mechanism begins with contraction. When liquid metal is poured into a ceramic shell, it contains superheat. As it cools to the liquidus temperature, it contracts. This is liquid contraction. As it cools from the liquidus to the solidus, it contracts again. This is solidification contraction. After it is fully solid, it continues to contract as it cools to room temperature. This is solid contraction. The total volume contraction is the sum of the three. The first two are responsible for the volume deficit that becomes shrinkage cavities and porosity.
For a given alloy, I express liquid contraction as:
$$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}} = \alpha_{V,\text{liquid}} (t_{\text{pour}} – t_{\text{liquid}}) \times 100\% $$
where \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}}\) is the liquid volume contraction rate, \(\alpha_{V,\text{liquid}}\) is the average volume contraction coefficient of the liquid from the pouring temperature \(t_{\text{pour}}\) to the liquidus temperature \(t_{\text{liquid}}\), and \(t_{\text{pour}} – t_{\text{liquid}}\) is the superheat. For carbon steel, \(\alpha_{V,\text{liquid}}\) is often taken as \(1.6 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{°C}^{-1}\).
Solidification contraction is expressed as:
$$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}} = f(\omega_C, \text{alloying elements}) $$
For medium-carbon steel, I often take \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}}\) as about \(3\%\). The value depends strongly on carbon content and other elements.
Solid contraction is expressed as:
$$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}} = \alpha_{V,\text{solid}} (t_{\text{solid}} – t_{\text{room}}) \times 100\% $$
and the linear solid contraction is:
$$ \varepsilon = \alpha (t_{\text{solid}} – t_{\text{room}}) \times 100\% $$
where \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}}\) and \(\varepsilon\) are the solid volume and linear contraction rates, \(\alpha_{V,\text{solid}}\) and \(\alpha\) are the corresponding coefficients, \(t_{\text{solid}}\) is the solidus temperature, and \(t_{\text{room}}\) is room temperature. For steel, the linear solid contraction is roughly one third of the volume contraction. A common value is \(2.4\%\), but it varies with carbon and other elements.
The total volume contraction from pouring to room temperature is:
$$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{total}} = \varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}} + \varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}} + \varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}} $$
For a plain carbon steel such as ZG270-500, with 100 °C superheat, I have used measured values of \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}} = 1.6\%\), \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}} = 3.0\%\), and \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}} = 7.2\%\). Thus:
$$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{total}} = 1.6\% + 3.0\% + 7.2\% = 11.8\% $$
In real lost wax casting, this total is reduced by gas evolution, by shell and core restraint, and by the casting geometry. Nevertheless, the equation explains why feeding is so important. If 11.8% of the volume is lost as the metal cools, and no liquid metal replaces it, the deficit must appear as a cavity or as porosity.
| Carbon content \(\omega_C\) (%) | Solidification volume contraction \(\varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}}\) (%) |
|---|---|
| 0.10 | 2.0 |
| 0.35 | 3.0 |
| 0.45 | 4.3 |
| 0.70 | 5.3 |
| Carbon content \(\omega_C\) (%) | Pre-pearlite contraction \(\varepsilon_{\text{pearlite}}\) (%) | Eutectoid expansion \(\varepsilon_{\gamma \to \alpha}\) (%) | Post-pearlite contraction \(\varepsilon_{\text{post-pearlite}}\) (%) | Total solid linear contraction \(\varepsilon\) (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.08 | 1.42 | 0.11 | 1.16 | 2.47 |
| 0.14 | 1.51 | 0.11 | 1.06 | 2.46 |
| 0.35 | 1.47 | 0.11 | 1.04 | 2.40 |
| 0.45 | 1.39 | 0.11 | 1.07 | 2.35 |
| 0.55 | 1.35 | 0.09 | 1.05 | 2.31 |
| 0.90 | 1.21 | 0.01 | 0.98 | 2.18 |
The formation of a concentrated shrinkage cavity can be described step by step for a cylindrical lost wax casting. When the metal enters the mold cavity, it is level with the top. Because the shell extracts heat, the metal in contact with the shell falls below the liquidus first and forms a thin solid shell. The liquid inside the shell contracts as it cools, and the top surface drops. As cooling continues, the shell thickens. The volume lost by liquid and solidification contraction is greater than the solid contraction of the already solidified shell, so the liquid pulls away from the top. A large void appears. At complete solidification, the void is an approximately inverted-cone cavity. Then solid contraction reduces both the external dimensions and the cavity volume slightly. That is the classic sequence I see in lost wax casting when the top is not fed.
Causes of Shrinkage Defects in Lost Wax Casting
I group the causes into several categories. Each category can be controlled, but they interact. For example, a poor gating design may be made worse by a high pouring temperature, or a good gating design may be defeated by a shell that cools too slowly at a local hot spot.
| Cause category | Mechanism in lost wax casting | Typical result |
|---|---|---|
| Unreasonable gating system | Does not promote directional solidification or sufficient feeding | Shrinkage at last solidification site |
| Unreasonable casting structure | Abrupt section changes, isolated thick sections, poor fillets, new hot spots | Feeding paths blocked or hot spots created |
| High liquid and solidification contraction | Alloy composition and superheat increase volume deficit | Larger cavity volume |
| Improper pouring conditions | Fast pouring increases liquid temperature and reduces feeding time | Larger cavity volume |
| Poor shell cooling capacity | Slow local solidification delays the last liquid | More shrinkage and porosity |
| Poor local heat dissipation | Re-entrant corners, cluster shadows, thick shell sections | Corner shrinkage and local porosity |
| Insufficient pressure head | Reduced flow and feeding force | Incomplete feeding in remote regions |
Gating design is the most common cause I encounter. If the gating system cannot establish directional solidification, the casting will not feed properly. Directional solidification means controlling the freezing process so that the metal solidifies progressively toward the riser or sprue. The latest freezing part is kept in the gating system, not in the casting. When the gate and riser are cut off, the shrinkage cavity is removed with them. If the gating design is wrong, the last liquid freezes inside the casting and leaves a cavity.
I have seen several stages of correction. In the first, isotherm lines show a cavity in the middle and upper part. In the second, a riser is added, and the upper cavity moves into the riser, but a middle cavity remains. In the third, the riser is enlarged, and the middle cavity also moves into the riser, but a shrinkage tail still extends into the upper casting. In the fourth, the riser is enlarged further and given a taper, and the cavity is completely eliminated. This sequence shows that feeding is not a matter of simply making the riser bigger; the geometry of the feed path must also be correct.
Casting structure is another major cause. If section sizes change abruptly, the thin section freezes quickly and blocks the feed path to the thick section. An isolated thick section cannot be fed from a remote riser. A fillet that is too small creates a sharp transition and a rapid change in modulus. A fillet that is too large creates a new hot spot. For parts converted from forgings or weldments, the geometry may not have been redesigned for casting, so the feed paths are poor. In lost wax casting, these problems are especially visible because the shell can be preheated and the alloy can be poured at high temperature, but the fundamental modulus differences remain.
Alloy contraction also matters. The larger the liquid contraction, the larger the potential cavity volume. For alloys that do not expand on solidification, and when feeding is absent, the liquid contraction is proportional to the superheat and the contraction coefficient. However, the relationship is not always simple. If the gating system has feeding capacity, lowering the pouring temperature can reduce liquid contraction but may also reduce the feeding capacity. If the gating system freezes too early, the cavity volume can increase. Conversely, a moderate increase in superheat can improve feeding and reduce the final cavity volume. This is why I always evaluate pouring temperature together with gate design, not in isolation.
Solidification contraction also increases cavity volume. If deoxidation is incomplete, gas is evolved during solidification. If the gas cannot float out or enter an existing cavity, it remains among the dendrites as dispersed porosity. This reduces the apparent solidification volume contraction but expands the porosity zone. In other words, gas can hide some shrinkage but make the porosity more widespread.
Pouring conditions are also critical. A faster pour gives the metal less time to lose heat. When pouring is complete, the metal in the cavity is hotter, so liquid contraction is greater. More importantly, the metal poured first has less time to be fed by the metal poured later. The final cavity volume increases. Shell cooling capacity has a similar effect. If the shell cools slowly, the metal solidifies slowly. The first metal to enter contracts, but the later metal feeds it less effectively, and the final cavity is larger. If the solidification time can be made equal to the pouring time, the casting can solidify without shrinkage. This is the principle of continuous casting, and it is a useful ideal to keep in mind even in lost wax casting.
Local heat dissipation is a common cause of corner shrinkage. A re-entrant corner has a larger effective thermal mass and poorer heat extraction. It solidifies later than the surrounding walls. If it cannot be fed, a corner cavity forms. In a multi-part tree, the shadowing effect can also make a region cool more slowly. Finally, if the pressure head is too low, the feed metal flows too slowly, and remote regions are not fed. The result is a shrinkage cavity in the last region to solidify.
Prevention of Shrinkage Defects in Lost Wax Casting
The basic principle is simple: make the casting solidify directionally and leave the shrinkage cavity in the gating system. I apply this principle through gating design, casting structure modification, alloy and pouring control, local cooling improvement, and pressure head adjustment. The following sections summarize the practical measures I use in lost wax casting.
Gating System Design
The gating system in lost wax casting usually includes a pouring cup, sprue, runner, and gates. When necessary, it also includes a slag trap, buffer, and vent. The pouring cup receives the metal and establishes a pressure head for filling and feeding. Its top is usually 70 to 100 mm above the wax pattern. The sprue is the support for shell building and often serves as a riser. To ensure feeding, the sprue cross-sectional area is often 1.4 times the total gate area. The runner distributes metal, traps slag, and can feed. If it feeds, its area is 1.1 to 1.3 times the sprue area. If it does not feed, its area is 0.7 to 1.0 times the sprue area. The gate is the channel between the runner or sprue and the casting. It controls filling, solidification, feeding, stress, and defects such as shrinkage, porosity, hot tearing, and distortion. It also affects cleaning, machining, and surface quality. For this reason, gate design is the most critical part of gating design in lost wax casting.
| Gating component | Function | Recommended area relationship |
|---|---|---|
| Pouring cup | Receive metal, establish pressure head | Top 70–100 mm above pattern |
| Sprue | Support shell, often acts as riser | 1.4 times total gate area |
| Runner (feeding) | Distribute metal, trap slag, feed | 1.1–1.3 times sprue area |
| Runner (non-feeding) | Distribute metal, trap slag | 0.7–1.0 times sprue area |
| Gate | Control filling and feeding into casting | See gate design equations below |
When I design a gate for lost wax casting, I consider position, number, shape, length, and cross-sectional size. The position must avoid direct impact on cores and thin shell sections, prevent turbulence and eddies, and avoid local overheating that softens the shell. From the feeding standpoint, the gate should be placed at the hot spot so that directional solidification can occur. The number of gates should be as small as possible, usually one, but complex parts with scattered hot spots and high integrity requirements may need two or more. The shape can be rectangular, circular, square, or fan-shaped, depending on the casting geometry at the gate location. The length is typically 8 to 12 mm for an easily knocked-off gate and 10 to 15 mm for a flame-cut gate.
The cross-sectional size can be determined by the hot-spot circle method or the equivalent hot-spot method. In the hot-spot circle method, the gate diameter is related to the hot-spot diameter by:
$$ D_{\text{gate}} = K D_{\text{hotspot}} $$
where \(K\) is usually 0.7 to 0.9. In the equivalent hot-spot method, the casting hot spot is converted into one or more simple units, such as a cylinder, so that the unit has the same weight and solidification modulus as the hot spot. Then the same ratio method is used to find the gate size. If the gate is too large, the metal in the gate neck remains liquid until the end. Because no other liquid is available to feed it, a shrinkage cavity can form at the gate-casting junction. If the gate is too small, it freezes early and isolates the hot spot. The correct size is the one that keeps the feed path open just long enough.
Casting Structure Modification
I first analyze the casting structure and then apply normal allowances, draft, and machining stock as an initial design. Next, I identify the hot spots and divide the casting into feeding regions. If feeding is difficult, I adjust the process allowances to thicken or thin local areas, aim for uniform wall thickness, and increase fillets at transitions. If these measures are not enough, I use padding. Padding means adding thickness near the riser to establish a temperature gradient toward the riser. It increases the feeding channel and improves the feeding ability of the sprue or riser. For top-poured castings, when the wall thickness is fixed, the pad width increases with height. When the height is fixed, a thinner wall requires a wider feeding channel. Padding increases machining stock, so it must be used with care. Excessive padding defeats the purpose of lost wax casting, which is to produce near-net shapes.
Reducing Metal Contraction
Where the performance requirements allow, I select an alloy with lower liquid and solidification contraction. Once the casting structure and alloy composition are fixed, the freezing range, thermal conductivity, crystallization temperature, latent heat, and wall thickness are largely set. However, shell thermal storage, pouring conditions, shell preheat, and cooling after pouring are still available as process variables. Pouring temperature is especially important. If it is too high, liquid contraction increases, and if feeding is insufficient, the cavity volume increases. If it is too low, the gating system freezes early and loses feeding ability, which also increases the cavity volume. The best pouring temperature is the one that balances superheat against feeding capacity. In practice, I use high-temperature tapping and low-temperature pouring. For large modules, I use a fast-slow-refill pouring pattern to promote directional solidification and feeding. For top pouring, I use higher pouring temperature and slower pouring speed. For bottom pouring, I use lower pouring temperature and faster pouring speed.
Deoxidation and Gas Control
I ensure sufficient deoxidation during melting. Gas evolved during solidification can reduce the apparent solidification contraction, but it also expands the porosity zone. If the gas cannot float out or enter an existing cavity, it remains among the dendrites. In lost wax casting, this is particularly harmful because the shell is not permeable in the same way as a sand mold. Proper deoxidation, clean charge materials, and controlled melting reduce gas-related porosity and make shrinkage behavior more predictable.
Local Cooling Improvement
I improve local heat dissipation by arranging the tree properly. For multi-part trees, I keep an appropriate distance between wax patterns. For single-part trees, I place the hot spot near the edge of the module. At re-entrant corners, heat dissipation is poor. When necessary, I use chills in the shell-making process. Brass and stainless steel are preferred because carbon steel can oxidize during shell firing and bond poorly. Chills improve local cooling, increase feeding ability, and reduce or eliminate corner shrinkage. I also consider shell thickness and shell preheat. A thicker shell insulates more; a thinner shell cools faster. Local coating or local insulation can adjust the thermal gradient.
Pressure Head and Feeding Distance
A higher pressure head increases the flow rate and improves feeding. However, for ordinary castings, the effective feeding distance decreases as wall thickness increases. Increasing riser diameter and height alone cannot always achieve effective feeding. If the riser is too high, it may only feed the lower part of the casting, and a secondary shrinkage cavity can remain in the upper part. For this reason, I often use insulating risers and exothermic covers together. The cover reduces and delays solidification of the top of the riser, preventing a secondary cavity from forming at the top. If necessary, I change to centrifugal or pressure-assisted pouring. These methods are more complex, but they can solve feeding problems that cannot be solved by gravity pouring alone.
| Prevention method | Expected effect | Practical notes in lost wax casting |
|---|---|---|
| Directional gating design | Moves shrinkage into sprue or riser | Use sprue as riser when possible; balance gate size |
| Uniform wall thickness | Reduces isolated hot spots | Adjust process allowances and fillets |
| Padding | Improves feed path near riser | Increases machining stock; use selectively |
| Alloy selection | Lowers liquid and solidification contraction | Check performance requirements first |
| Pouring temperature control | Balances superheat and feeding | High-temperature tapping, low-temperature pouring |
| Deoxidation | Reduces gas porosity | Clean melt, proper deoxidizer |
| Chills | Improves local cooling | Brass or stainless steel preferred |
| Insulating riser and exothermic cover | Keeps riser liquid longer | Prevents secondary shrinkage |
| Higher pressure head | Improves feeding flow | Effective feeding distance still limited |
Application Case in Lost Wax Casting
I now describe a field case that shows how the principles above can be applied. The part was a critical lost wax casting for mining equipment. It weighed about 16 kg. The service requirement was more than 10,000 meters of advance. In the original condition, the part failed by wear after only 3,000 to 4,000 meters. This increased the customer’s operating cost and reduced the economic benefit for both the customer and the manufacturer. Inspection showed severe shrinkage cavities and axial shrinkage porosity on the wear surface. These defects reduced wear resistance and caused early failure. The material was a low-alloy steel, and the shrinkage defects were the dominant cause of the short life.
Rare earth elements can improve the fluidity of liquid metal, increase feeding ability, reduce shrinkage cavities and porosity, improve casting process performance, and improve mechanical properties. In steel, rare earth elements also purify, modify, and alloy the material. I decided to add a rare earth alloy to the steel and to adjust the casting process. The target material was ZG20CrMnMoRe. The chemical composition is shown in the following table.
| Element | C | Si | Mn | Cr | Mo | P | S | Re |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Content (%) | 0.15–0.25 | 0.40–0.75 | 0.90–1.20 | 1.10–1.40 | 0.20–0.30 | ≤0.04 | ≤0.04 | 0.15 added |
I tested three addition methods in a 500 kg coreless induction furnace with an acid lining. The results showed that ladle injection gave a higher recovery and a more stable rare earth residual. The mechanical properties of the castings were also more stable. The comparison is shown below.
| Addition method | Rare earth recovery (%) | Rare earth residual (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Furnace insertion | Decreases with pouring time | Decreases with pouring time |
| Furnace addition | 15–25 | 0.02–0.04 |
| Ladle injection | 50–80 | 0.08–0.12 |
The addition amount must be appropriate. Too much rare earth degrades the steel; too little has no effect. A published formula can be used for estimation:
$$ Re_{\text{addition}} = 5.85([O]_{\text{initial}} – [O]_{\text{residual}}) + 2.93([S]_{\text{initial}} – [S]_{\text{residual}}) + Re_{\text{residual}} $$
This formula is useful, but it does not include rare earth burn loss. In practice, the addition must satisfy four requirements: deoxidation, desulfurization, burn loss, and residual. To find the best addition amount, I used the same furnace of metal and the ladle injection method. I added different amounts of rare earth alloy: 0, 0.15%, 0.30%, and 0.40%. The test bars were normalized at 900–920 °C for 1 hour, tempered at 650–680 °C for 2 hours, carburized at 920–940 °C for 14 hours, quenched at 830–850 °C for 20 minutes, and tempered at 180–200 °C for 1 hour. The mechanical properties are shown below.
| Rare earth addition (%) | Tensile strength (MPa), 1-a | Tensile strength (MPa), 2-a | Impact toughness (J/cm²), 1-b | Impact toughness (J/cm²), 2-b |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 217 | 212 | 1.08 | 3.07 |
| 0.15 | 236 | 312 | 1.58 | 5.17 |
| 0.30 | 243 | 319 | 1.63 | 5.73 |
| 0.40 | 234 | 288 | 1.50 | 3.8 |
In the table, 1 refers to the base steel without rare earth, and 2 refers to the rare earth modified steel. Considering casting quality, cost, and economic benefit, I selected ladle injection with 0.15% rare earth alloy. At this level, the recovery was 50–80%, and the residual was 0.08–0.12%.
I then poured both the base steel and the rare earth modified steel from the same furnace. The rare earth modified steel was poured by ladle injection with 0.15% addition. The casting results are shown below. With rare earth, gas in the liquid metal formed rare earth compounds, so less gas was evolved before solidification. Feeding ability also increased. As a result, gas-related rejects were reduced, density increased, and shrinkage porosity was greatly reduced.
| Billet type | Number poured | Gas-related rejects | Density after nitric acid etching |
|---|---|---|---|
| With rare earth | 15 | 0 | Slight shrinkage porosity visible |
| Without rare earth | 10 | 2 | Severe shrinkage cavity and porosity visible |
The chemical composition before and after rare earth addition is shown below. The rare earth residual was 0.102% in the modified steel.
| Material | C | Si | Mn | Cr | Mo | S before Re | S after Re | Re residual |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base steel | 0.24 | 0.35 | 1.00 | 1.32 | 0.23 | 0.029 | — | 0 |
| Rare earth steel | 0.24 | 0.57 | 1.00 | 1.32 | 0.23 | 0.029 | 0.015 | 0.102 |
After normalizing and tempering, the test bars were machined into bending, impact, and wear specimens. After carburizing, quenching, and tempering, the mechanical properties were measured. The rare earth modified steel showed higher bending strength and much higher impact toughness. True carburized specimens, representing the carburized layer, improved by 50%. False carburized specimens, representing the core, improved by nearly three times. The wear test showed that the rare earth modified steel had 10–20% better wear resistance. The results are shown below.
| Material | Bending strength, true carburized (MPa) | Bending strength, false carburized (MPa) | Impact toughness, true carburized (J/cm²) | Impact toughness, false carburized (J/cm²) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base steel | 187 | 218 | 1.2 | 2.2 |
| Rare earth steel | 198 | 288 | 1.8 | 6.4 |
| Material | Hardness (HRC) | Revolutions | Mass loss (g) | Size reduction (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base steel | 59–61 | 5,000 | 0.2087 | 0.0825 |
| Base steel | 59–61 | 20,000 | 1.7770 | 0.3360 |
| Base steel | 59–61 | 40,000 | 3.7872 | 0.8810 |
| Rare earth steel | 60–62 | 5,000 | 0.1557 | 0.0500 |
| Rare earth steel | 60–62 | 20,000 | 1.2368 | 0.2250 |
| Rare earth steel | 60–62 | 40,000 | 3.2678 | 0.7170 |
The wear data are averages of five specimens. The reduced mass loss and reduced size loss show that the rare earth modified lost wax casting had better wear resistance.
The field test was carried out in a mine. The rock hardness was F = 12–16, the air pressure was 5–6 kg/cm², and the water pressure was 5–7 kg/cm². Two rare earth modified billets were installed and monitored for more than ten months. The advance records are shown below.
| Month | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Billet 1 (m) | 1000 | 1148.5 | 766 | 2267.5 | 1112.5 | 2016 | 1882 | 1228.3 | 965.5 | 745.5 | — | 13131.7 |
| Billet 2 (m) | 1020 | 1183 | 233 | 1237 | 134.2 | 1357.5 | 1389 | 635.5 | 1514 | 774.7 | — | 10675.7 |
After more than ten months of mine service, both rare earth modified billets exceeded 10,000 meters. This was more than twice the life of the original base steel billet. Later, I reduced the wall thickness of the billet and reduced machining allowances for turning and grinding. These changes improved the yield of the lost wax casting and further increased service life to more than three times the original. The result was incorporated into normal production.
Summary of Shrinkage Control in Lost Wax Casting
The most important rule I have learned is that reducing or eliminating shrinkage defects in lost wax casting means making the casting solidify directionally. In practice, I consider several factors together. First, is the casting structure itself reasonable? Second, is the gating system designed correctly? Third, if these two are not sufficient, can I adjust machining allowances or use padding to make earlier-solidifying regions cooler and later-solidifying regions hotter? Fourth, can I use shell temperature, pouring conditions, and local cooling to support directional solidification? The measures are interconnected. A change in one affects the others.
Directional solidification also has a cost. It creates larger temperature differences between different parts of the casting. These differences can produce residual stress and may lead to distortion or cracking. Therefore, I do not pursue directional solidification blindly. I balance feeding against stress and distortion. In many lost wax castings, the best solution is a compromise: enough directional solidification to eliminate harmful shrinkage, but not so much that the casting cracks or distorts.
The equations I use most often are summarized below. They help me estimate the volume deficit and the feeding requirements.
| Quantity | Equation | Typical value or note |
|---|---|---|
| Liquid contraction | $$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}} = \alpha_{V,\text{liquid}} (t_{\text{pour}} – t_{\text{liquid}}) \times 100\% $$ | \(\alpha_{V,\text{liquid}} \approx 1.6 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{°C}^{-1}\) for carbon steel |
| Solidification contraction | $$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}} = f(\omega_C, \text{alloying elements}) $$ | About 3% for medium-carbon steel |
| Solid contraction | $$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}} = \alpha_{V,\text{solid}} (t_{\text{solid}} – t_{\text{room}}) \times 100\% $$ | Linear value often about 2.4% for steel |
| Total contraction | $$ \varepsilon_{V,\text{total}} = \varepsilon_{V,\text{liquid}} + \varepsilon_{V,\text{solidification}} + \varepsilon_{V,\text{solid}} $$ | Example: 1.6% + 3.0% + 7.2% = 11.8% |
| Gate diameter | $$ D_{\text{gate}} = K D_{\text{hotspot}} $$ | \(K = 0.7 \sim 0.9\) |
| Rare earth addition estimate | $$ Re_{\text{addition}} = 5.85([O]_{\text{initial}} – [O]_{\text{residual}}) + 2.93([S]_{\text{initial}} – [S]_{\text{residual}}) + Re_{\text{residual}} $$ | Does not include burn loss; adjust by recovery |
In my opinion, the study of shrinkage defects in lost wax casting is never finished. Every new geometry, alloy, shell system, and tree arrangement creates a new thermal history. The defects are the visible result of that history. By combining sound gating design, structure modification, alloy control, pouring practice, local cooling, and pressure head management, I can reduce shrinkage cavities and porosity, improve yield, lower cost, and increase the service life of the final product. The field case with rare earth modification showed that a relatively small process change can produce a large improvement when it is based on a correct understanding of feeding and solidification. In lost wax casting, the goal is not simply to make a shape; it is to make a sound shape whose last liquid has been fed and whose shrinkage has been moved into the gating system where it can be removed.
I continue to use tables, equations, sectioning, simulation, and production trials together. No single method is sufficient. The most reliable approach is to predict the last solidification location, design the feed path to reach it, verify the design by simulation or trial, and then control the process variables that affect the thermal gradient. When I follow this approach, shrinkage defects in lost wax casting become manageable rather than mysterious.
