In the latter half of 2019, our cold rolling process began detecting varying degrees of slag inclusions during the rolling of automobile steel plates. These defects, at times severe, led to batch blockages and downgrades. Moreover, end-users faced part cracking during stamping operations due to these slag inclusions, sometimes resulting in irreparable scrap. The presence of slag inclusions in automobile steel slabs significantly impacts production efficiency and quality costs, making their continuous reduction a long-standing goal in steel manufacturing. From my perspective as a process engineer involved in this investigation, understanding and mitigating slag inclusions is critical for enhancing product reliability and customer satisfaction.
Slag inclusions manifest as elongated streaks parallel to the rolling direction on thin sheets (0.5–1.0 mm thick after rolling), often forming large cracks when severe. Through sampling and analysis of defect sites from user feedback, cross-sectional metallographic specimens were prepared. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) revealed subcutaneous fine inclusions composed of carbon, oxygen, fluorine, sodium, magnesium, aluminum, silicon, sulfur, calcium, titanium, and iron. This confirms that the defects originate from slag inclusions during steelmaking. The composition analysis indicates complex oxide-sulfide mixtures, emphasizing the multifaceted nature of slag inclusions.

To quantify the elemental distribution, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) data can be summarized via a formula for inclusion composition. For instance, the weight percentage of an element \(i\) in slag inclusions can be expressed as: $$w_i = \frac{C_i}{\sum_{j=1}^{n} C_j} \times 100\%$$ where \(C_i\) is the count rate from EDS for element \(i\), and \(n\) is the number of elements detected. This helps in identifying dominant contributors to slag inclusions, such as aluminum and calcium oxides.
Slag inclusions in slabs primarily arise from mold flux entrapment on the steel surface in the continuous caster mold. When mold flux has a high melting point or poor fluidity, it can embed into the slab surface. Sources include ladle slag entering the tundish during delayed nozzle closure, erosion of tundish refractories and nozzles, and alumina inclusions from steelmaking. These contribute to slag inclusions either through internal entrainment or surface adhesion.
The formation process involves two mechanisms: entrainment into the steel bulk and adhesion to the slab surface. During casting, asymmetric flow fields near the submerged entry nozzle (SEN) due to turbulence can create vortices, especially with meniscus fluctuations. This increases the probability of slag inclusions. As casting speed rises, upward steel flow accelerates meniscus velocity, intensifying slag entrainment. Near the narrow face of the mold, slag entrapment is common due to steel flow redirecting along the slag-steel interface, thinning the slag layer and exposing steel. The interfacial tension can drag slag particles into the steel, forming slag inclusions. Additionally, slag adhesion at the meniscus can become trapped under the oscillation marks, leading to permanent defects.
Key factors influencing slag inclusions are mold flux properties, argon blowing rate, meniscus stability, nozzle alignment, and casting speed. A table comparing mold flux properties for automobile steel versus other grades highlights differences:
| Property | Automobile Steel Flux | Other Fluxes |
|---|---|---|
| Melting Point (°C) | 1040–1120 | 910–1130 |
| Viscosity at 1300°C (Pa·s) | 0.17–0.45 | 0.09–0.13 |
| Basicity (CaO/SiO₂) | 0.87–1.18 | 1.1–1.2 |
The viscosity \(\eta\) of mold flux affects slag entrainment; higher viscosity reduces flowability but may increase slag inclusion risk if not optimized. An empirical relation for slag entrainment probability \(P_e\) can be: $$P_e = k \cdot \frac{\rho_s \cdot v^2}{\eta \cdot \sigma}$$ where \(\rho_s\) is steel density, \(v\) is meniscus velocity, \(\sigma\) is interfacial tension, and \(k\) is a constant. This shows how viscosity and flow dynamics interplay in slag inclusion formation.
Excessive argon blowing in the SEN, aimed at preventing nozzle clogging, can exacerbate meniscus turbulence. Data from our plant indicated that high argon flow rates correlated with increased slag inclusion complaints. By reducing argon equivalent flow from an average of 2.2 to 1.6 (a 27.8% decrease), we observed fewer slag inclusions. The argon flow rate \(Q_{Ar}\) should be optimized based on steel grade: $$Q_{Ar} = \alpha \cdot \left( \frac{T_{steel} – T_{liquidus}}{T_{ref}} \right)$$ where \(\alpha\) is a material constant, \(T_{steel}\) is steel temperature, \(T_{liquidus}\) is liquidus temperature, and \(T_{ref}\) is a reference temperature.
Meniscus stability is crucial; large fluctuations promote slag entrainment. We implemented measures to stabilize the meniscus, improving the compliance index from 5.05 to 9.33 (a 40% increase). Meniscus fluctuation amplitude \(A\) can be modeled as: $$A = \beta \cdot \frac{\Delta v}{h} \cdot \exp(-\gamma \cdot t)$$ where \(\Delta v\) is velocity variation, \(h\) is mold depth, \(\gamma\) is damping coefficient, and \(t\) is time. Controlling this reduces slag inclusion incidence.
Casting speed directly affects slag inclusions. Higher speeds increase steel flow impact, deepening vortex formation and hindering inclusion flotation. We adopted constant speed casting, raising the constant rate from 82.83% to 93.18%. The inclusion flotation time \(t_f\) can be estimated via Stokes’ law: $$t_f = \frac{9 \eta h}{2g r^2 (\rho_s – \rho_i)}$$ where \(g\) is gravity, \(r\) is inclusion radius, \(\rho_i\) is inclusion density, and \(h\) is distance to the surface. Faster casting reduces \(t_f\), increasing slag inclusion retention.
Nozzle alignment and immersion depth also matter. Misalignment causes biased flow, aggravating slag inclusions. Optimal immersion depth \(d_{opt}\) balances slag entrainment and inclusion removal: $$d_{opt} = L \cdot \left( \frac{\eta}{\rho_s v_{cast}} \right)^{0.5}$$ where \(L\) is mold width and \(v_{cast}\) is casting speed. We ensured precise alignment and depth control to minimize defects.
Improvement strategies included preventing slag carryover, controlling argon flow, stabilizing the meniscus, and maintaining constant casting speed. For slag carryover, enhancing ladle slag detection systems and using larger tundishes reduced ingress. Mold flux was tailored for automobile steel, focusing on viscosity and basicity adjustments. Argon flow optimization involved nozzle redesign and pipeline maintenance. Meniscus stability was achieved through sensor calibration and operational parameter tweaks. Constant speed casting required logistics coordination and strict speed protocols.
The results were significant: slag inclusion blockage rates dropped from 6.3% to 3.6%, and user complaints decreased by 50%, with direct economic losses falling 70%. This underscores the importance of integrated process control. The economic impact can be summarized via a cost-benefit formula: $$\Delta C = (R_b \cdot C_b + R_u \cdot C_u) – C_i$$ where \(\Delta C\) is net cost saving, \(R_b\) is reduction in blockage rate, \(C_b\) is cost per blockage, \(R_u\) is reduction in user claims, \(C_u\) is cost per claim, and \(C_i\) is implementation cost. Our data shows positive \(\Delta C\), highlighting the value of addressing slag inclusions.
In conclusion, controlling slag inclusions hinges on meniscus stability, optimized argon blowing, constant casting speed, and steel cleanliness. These measures not only cut defects but also lower costs, proving essential for competitive automobile steel production. Future work may explore advanced modeling to predict slag inclusion formation under varying conditions, further refining our approach to minimize these detrimental defects in slabs and final products.
