Development and Heat Treatment of High-Nitrogen Martensitic Steel Castings for Ultra-Supercritical Applications

In the pursuit of green industrial transformation, ultra-supercritical (USC) coal-fired power generation technology has rapidly advanced due to its potential to reduce coal consumption and carbon emissions. The core of this technology lies in the development of advanced heat-resistant materials capable of withstanding extreme temperatures and pressures. Among these, 9–12% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steels have emerged as preferred structural materials for components like cylinders and rotors in 600°C-class USC plants, owing to their low thermal expansion, high thermal conductivity, excellent thermal fatigue resistance, and cost-effectiveness. However, a critical limitation persists: the creep strength of these steels degrades significantly during long-term service at high temperatures, primarily due to the coarsening of precipitates such as M23C6 carbides. This degradation restricts their application in next-generation USC systems operating at higher temperatures and pressures. Recent studies have highlighted that MN-type nitrides exhibit superior structural and thermal stability compared to M23C6, offering a promising avenue for enhancing high-temperature performance. Inspired by this, our research focuses on designing and developing a novel high-nitrogen martensitic heat-resistant steel casting, where nitride precipitation strengthening plays a dominant role. This article delves into the heat treatment optimization, phase transformation analysis, and microstructural characterization of this advanced steel casting, aiming to contribute to the evolution of durable materials for USC power plants.

Steel castings are integral to heavy industrial applications, particularly in energy sectors where complex geometries and high integrity are required. The manufacturing of steel castings involves precise control over composition and processing to achieve desired properties. In this context, we explore a high-nitrogen variant of 9% Cr martensitic steel, with a nitrogen content of 0.27 wt.%, designed to leverage nitride precipitates for enhanced stability. The chemical composition of our steel casting is detailed in Table 1, emphasizing low carbon and high nitrogen to favor nitride formation over carbides. This design philosophy aligns with the goal of improving creep resistance through thermally stable precipitates.

Table 1: Chemical Composition of the High-Nitrogen Martensitic Steel Casting (wt.%)
C N Cr V Nb W Co Mo Mn Si Ni
0.01 0.27 9.1 0.6 0.03 7.1 2.77 0.9 0.08 0.05 0.02

The development of high-performance steel castings necessitates a thorough understanding of phase transformations and heat treatment responses. We employed Thermo-Calc software to simulate the equilibrium phase fractions as a function of temperature, ranging from 400°C to 1600°C. The simulation revealed key transformation temperatures: the austenite start (As) temperature at approximately 830°C and the complete austenitization temperature around 1020°C. Furthermore, the phase diagram indicated coexistence regions, such as austenite + Laves + MN between 870°C and 1040°C, and austenite + δ-ferrite + MN between 1040°C and 1400°C. These insights guided our heat treatment strategy to minimize δ-ferrite formation, which is detrimental to toughness and creep strength. To complement the simulation, differential thermal analysis (DTA) was conducted on homogenized samples, identifying actual transformation peaks: an inflection at 850°C corresponding to ferrite-to-austenite transformation, an exothermic peak at 1015°C associated with δ-ferrite formation, and an endothermic peak at 1160°C likely due to MX precipitate dissolution. Based on these results, we formulated a three-stage heat treatment process: homogenization, normalization, and tempering, tailored to achieve a balanced microstructure with fine nitride dispersions.

Heat treatment is a critical step in optimizing the properties of steel castings. For our high-nitrogen martensitic steel casting, we established the following optimized parameters: homogenization at 1000°C for 10 hours, normalization at 1030°C for 2 hours, and tempering at 760°C for 2 hours, all followed by air cooling. The homogenization aims to dissolve coarse primary precipitates and ensure compositional uniformity, while normalization produces a fully martensitic structure with minimal δ-ferrite. Tempering facilitates the precipitation of fine nitrides and relieves internal stresses. The selection of these temperatures was driven by the need to avoid excessive δ-ferrite formation, as observed in preliminary tests at higher temperatures. For instance, homogenization at 1130°C led to about 30% δ-ferrite, which could compromise mechanical properties. Similarly, normalization above 1080°C increased δ-ferrite content and coarsened precipitates. Thus, our optimized protocol prioritizes microstructural refinement.

Table 2: Optimized Heat Treatment Parameters for the High-Nitrogen Martensitic Steel Casting
Stage Temperature (°C) Time (hours) Cooling
Homogenization 1000 10 Air cool
Normalization 1030 2 Air cool
Tempering 760 2 Air cool

The manufacturing of steel castings often involves complex processes to achieve desired shapes and properties.

This image illustrates a typical steel casting manufacturing setup, highlighting the importance of precision in foundry operations. In our case, the steel casting was produced via pressurized vacuum induction melting, ensuring high purity and controlled nitrogen addition. The as-cast microstructure exhibited martensitic laths with some δ-ferrite and coarse nitride inclusions, necessitating further heat treatment for refinement.

Microstructural characterization of the tempered steel casting revealed a mixed structure of tempered lath martensite and a small amount of δ-ferrite. The martensite laths had an average width of approximately 220 nm, measured from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images. Precipitates were distributed both at lath boundaries and within the laths. At the boundaries, Laves phase particles (Fe2W) with sizes ranging from 100 to 300 nm were observed, serving to pin the boundaries and hinder lath coarsening. However, Laves phases are known to coarsen rapidly during creep, potentially initiating voids and reducing creep strength. Their growth kinetics can be described by the Ostwald ripening equation: $$ r^3 – r_0^3 = k t $$ where \( r \) is the particle radius at time \( t \), \( r_0 \) is the initial radius, and \( k \) is a rate constant dependent on temperature and diffusion coefficients. To mitigate coarsening, future iterations of steel castings might consider reducing tungsten content, as \( k \) is proportional to solute concentration.

Within the martensite laths, a multitude of fine nitride precipitates were identified, including MN-type (e.g., NbN), M2N-type (e.g., Cr2N), and M6N-type (e.g., Fe4W2N). These nitrides varied in size from a few nanometers to about 200 nm, contributing to multi-scale strengthening. The volume fraction of MN-type precipitates was estimated at 5.8 wt.% from X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of extracted powders. The strengthening mechanisms in steel castings can be quantified using the Orowan equation for precipitation strengthening: $$ \Delta \sigma_p = \frac{0.4 G b}{\pi \sqrt{1-\nu}} \frac{\ln(2\bar{r}/b)}{\lambda} $$ where \( \Delta \sigma_p \) is the increase in yield strength due to precipitates, \( G \) is the shear modulus, \( b \) is the Burgers vector, \( \nu \) is Poisson’s ratio, \( \bar{r} \) is the average precipitate radius, and \( \lambda \) is the inter-precipitate spacing. For our steel casting, the high density of nano-scale MN nitrides reduces \( \lambda \), enhancing strength. Additionally, boundary strengthening from lath boundaries follows the Hall-Petch relationship: $$ \sigma_y = \sigma_0 + k_y d^{-1/2} $$ where \( \sigma_y \) is the yield strength, \( \sigma_0 \) is the friction stress, \( k_y \) is a constant, and \( d \) is the lath width. The fine lath structure (220 nm) contributes significantly to strength.

The mechanical properties of steel castings are paramount for their application in USC plants. Tensile tests conducted at 650°C demonstrated that our high-nitrogen martensitic steel casting achieves an ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of (386 ± 22) MPa, yield strength (YS) of (263.67 ± 15) MPa, and elongation of (36.22 ± 2)%. These values surpass those of conventional CB2 steel castings under similar conditions, highlighting the efficacy of nitride strengthening. The enhanced performance stems from the synergistic effects of solid solution strengthening by nitrogen, precipitation strengthening by stable nitrides, and boundary strengthening. The role of nitrogen in steel castings extends beyond precipitation; as an interstitial atom, nitrogen induces greater lattice distortion than carbon, increasing friction stress. This can be expressed as: $$ \sigma_{ss} = k_c C^{1/2} $$ where \( \sigma_{ss} \) is solid solution strengthening, \( k_c \) is a constant, and \( C \) is the solute concentration. With 0.27 wt.% N, our steel casting benefits substantially from this mechanism.

Table 3: Comparison of Mechanical Properties at 650°C for Different Steel Castings
Steel Casting Type Ultimate Tensile Strength (MPa) Yield Strength (MPa) Elongation (%)
High-Nitrogen Martensitic (This Work) 386 ± 22 263.67 ± 15 36.22 ± 2
Conventional CB2 ~300 (estimated) ~200 (estimated) ~25 (estimated)
Typical 9Cr Steels 350-400 250-300 20-30

Phase transformation analysis during heat treatment is crucial for optimizing steel castings. The dissolution and precipitation behaviors of various phases were studied through TEM and XRD. In the tempered condition, the absence of M23C6 carbides was notable, confirming the success of our composition design in favoring nitrides. Instead, multiple nitride types coexisted, providing thermal stability. The kinetics of nitride precipitation during tempering can be modeled using the Johnson-Mehl-Avrami-Kolmogorov (JMAK) equation: $$ f = 1 – \exp(-k t^n) $$ where \( f \) is the transformed fraction, \( k \) is a rate constant, and \( n \) is the Avrami exponent. For our steel casting, isothermal tempering at 760°C likely follows diffusion-controlled growth with \( n \approx 1.5 \). Furthermore, the stability of MN precipitates against coarsening is attributed to their low interfacial energy and slow diffusion rates, which can be described by the Lifshitz-Slyozov-Wagner theory: $$ \bar{r}^3 – \bar{r}_0^3 = \frac{8 \gamma D C_\infty V_m}{9 RT} t $$ where \( \gamma \) is interfacial energy, \( D \) is diffusion coefficient, \( C_\infty \) is equilibrium solubility, \( V_m \) is molar volume, \( R \) is gas constant, and \( T \) is temperature. The high melting point of nitrides like NbN results in low \( C_\infty \), slowing coarsening.

The application of steel castings in USC environments requires long-term creep resistance. Our high-nitrogen design addresses this by replacing unstable carbides with nitrides. Creep deformation in steel castings often follows Norton’s law: $$ \dot{\epsilon} = A \sigma^n \exp\left(-\frac{Q}{RT}\right) $$ where \( \dot{\epsilon} \) is creep rate, \( A \) is a constant, \( \sigma \) is stress, \( n \) is stress exponent, and \( Q \) is activation energy. The fine nitride dispersions in our steel casting reduce \( \dot{\epsilon} \) by impeding dislocation climb and glide. Additionally, the lath structure stabilized by boundary precipitates delays recovery and recrystallization. Future work will involve creep testing to quantify these benefits, but preliminary tensile data are promising.

In summary, the development of high-nitrogen martensitic steel castings represents a significant advancement for ultra-supercritical power generation. Through tailored heat treatment—homogenization at 1000°C for 10 h, normalization at 1030°C for 2 h, and tempering at 760°C for 2 h—we achieved a microstructure comprising tempered lath martensite with an average width of 220 nm, minimal δ-ferrite, and multi-scale nitride precipitates (MN, M2N, M6N). These nitrides provide superior thermal stability compared to traditional carbides, enhancing high-temperature strength and ductility. The steel casting exhibits excellent tensile properties at 650°C, with UTS of 386 MPa, YS of 264 MPa, and elongation of 36%. The use of steel castings in such demanding applications underscores the importance of material innovation. By leveraging nitrogen as a key alloying element, we have demonstrated a pathway to improve the performance and longevity of components in USC plants. Further optimization, such as adjusting tungsten content to control Laves phase coarsening, could yield even better creep resistance. This research contributes to the broader goal of developing sustainable energy technologies through advanced steel castings.

Scroll to Top