Research on Casting Process for High-Strength Low-Stress Machine Tool Bed Castings

In the manufacturing industry, cast iron remains a dominant structural material, particularly for machine tool castings, accounting for approximately 70% of the total weight of machine tool products. The evolution of modern machine tools toward higher loads, efficiency, and precision demands cast iron materials with enhanced strength, stiffness, dimensional accuracy, and stability. Among these, HT300 gray cast iron is a primary material for machine tool beds. However, challenges such as significant wall thickness variations, non-uniform hardness, high section sensitivity, and substantial internal stresses often lead to deformation after machining and poor dimensional stability. Traditionally, these issues are mitigated through one or multiple artificial aging treatments, which increase production costs and reduce efficiency. Therefore, optimizing the chemical composition to achieve high strength and low stress in machine tool castings is crucial. This study investigates the casting process for HT300 high-strength low-stress machine tool bed castings, focusing on the effects of silicon-to-carbon ratio (Si/C) and alloying elements on mechanical properties, section sensitivity, residual stress, and chill tendency.

To systematically evaluate the impact of chemical composition on the performance of machine tool castings, I designed an experimental matrix involving 18 different chemical compositions of gray cast iron. The compositions varied within the following ranges: carbon (C) content from 2.85% to 3.25%, silicon (Si) from 1.50% to 2.60%, manganese (Mn) from 0.80% to 1.00%, phosphorus (P) from 0.040% to 0.070%, sulfur (S) below 0.100%, and chromium (Cr) additions up to 0.35% for selected groups. The carbon equivalent (CE) was calculated using a simplified formula that focuses on carbon and silicon, as phosphorus’s contribution is minimal in this context. The CE is defined as:

$$CE = C + \frac{1}{3}Si$$

This formula helps in assessing the combined effect of carbon and silicon on the cast iron’s properties. The Si/C ratio was computed as:

$$Si/C = \frac{Si}{C}$$

For each composition, I prepared test bars with diameters of 30 mm, 50 mm, 90 mm, and 120 mm to evaluate mechanical properties and section sensitivity. Additionally, stress frames and triangular test blocks were cast to measure residual stress and chill tendency, respectively. All specimens were produced using resin sand molds, with the same batch of molten iron poured for each composition to ensure consistency. The melting was conducted in a 6,000 kg medium-frequency induction furnace, and the iron was inoculated with 0.6–0.7% SiFe75 inoculant via a pouring method. The pouring temperature was maintained between 1,350°C and 1,380°C, with a tapping temperature above 1,430°C.

The mechanical properties, including tensile strength and Brinell hardness, were tested for all specimen sizes. Tensile tests were performed using a hydraulic universal testing machine, while hardness was measured with a Brinell hardness tester. Metallographic examination was conducted on the 30 mm diameter test bars to observe graphite morphology and matrix structure. Residual stress was assessed by measuring the elongation of stress frames before and after cutting, with the elongation percentage calculated as:

$$\text{Elongation Percentage} = \frac{L_2 – L_1}{L_1} \times 100\%$$

where \(L_1\) is the initial distance between two marked points on the stress frame, and \(L_2\) is the distance after cutting. Lower elongation percentages indicate lower residual stresses. Chill tendency was evaluated by measuring the white iron depth on triangular test blocks for selected compositions.

The results from the 18 compositions are summarized in the following tables, which provide a comprehensive overview of the chemical compositions, mechanical properties, and derived parameters. These data form the basis for analyzing the effects of Si/C ratio and alloying on machine tool castings.

Group No. C (%) Si (%) Mn (%) P (%) S (%) Cr (%) CE (%) Si/C
1 2.90 1.60 0.95 0.042 0.092 – 3.43 0.55
2 2.88 1.98 0.91 0.055 0.084 – 3.54 0.69
3 2.92 2.10 0.92 0.054 0.100 0.35 3.62 0.72
4 2.92 2.20 1.00 0.050 0.100 – 3.65 0.75
5 2.95 2.12 0.80 0.054 0.082 – 3.66 0.72
6 2.94 2.61 0.87 0.043 0.092 – 3.81 0.89
7 3.02 1.61 0.80 0.043 0.064 – 3.56 0.53
8 2.98 2.03 0.96 0.052 0.100 – 3.66 0.68
9 2.98 2.03 0.99 0.050 0.098 0.30 3.66 0.68
10 2.98 2.35 0.88 0.059 0.100 – 3.76 0.79
11 3.20 1.55 0.98 0.049 0.098 – 3.72 0.48
12 3.20 1.55 0.99 0.052 0.096 0.30 3.72 0.48
13 3.15 1.60 0.96 0.056 0.086 – 3.68 0.51
14 3.23 1.55 0.97 0.062 0.095 – 3.75 0.48
15 3.15 1.59 1.00 0.060 0.096 0.30 3.68 0.50
16 3.14 2.00 0.80 0.042 0.094 – 3.81 0.64
17 3.22 2.16 0.85 0.048 0.074 – 3.94 0.67
18 3.16 2.55 0.99 0.056 0.095 – 4.01 0.81

The mechanical properties, including tensile strength and Brinell hardness for different specimen sizes, are presented in the table below. This data is essential for understanding how composition affects the performance of machine tool castings across varying sections.

Group No. CE (%) Si/C Cr (%) Tensile Strength (MPa) for Specimen Diameter Hardness (HBW) for Specimen Diameter ΔRm (MPa) ΔHBW
30 mm 50 mm 90 mm 120 mm 30 mm 50 mm 90 mm 120 mm
1 3.43 0.55 – 348 328 285 245 233 217 192 181 103 52
2 3.54 0.69 – 365 345 319 268 237 219 201 190 97 47
3 3.62 0.72 0.35 352 342 304 285 235 230 225 220 67 15
4 3.65 0.75 – 355 325 298 262 238 218 201 193 93 45
5 3.66 0.72 – 315 282 245 221 219 206 191 180 94 39
6 3.81 0.89 – 320 289 262 235 227 212 195 179 85 48
7 3.56 0.53 – 300 275 238 198 217 208 185 158 102 59
8 3.66 0.68 – 330 305 275 235 225 210 195 179 95 46
9 3.66 0.68 0.30 352 328 302 281 241 235 219 208 71 33
10 3.76 0.79 – 300 271 252 212 227 210 196 180 88 47
11 3.72 0.48 – 275 245 198 158 211 199 175 155 117 56
12 3.72 0.48 0.30 310 285 250 225 223 209 198 181 85 42
13 3.68 0.51 – 281 260 208 165 215 205 178 161 116 54
14 3.75 0.48 – 283 261 203 162 218 210 180 165 121 53
15 3.68 0.50 0.30 341 323 291 260 233 225 205 192 81 41
16 3.81 0.64 – 275 248 192 168 207 192 165 156 107 52
17 3.94 0.67 – 250 225 185 155 201 189 162 152 95 49
18 4.01 0.81 – 235 205 188 155 195 178 160 148 80 47

From the data, it is evident that the tensile strength and hardness generally decrease with increasing CE, regardless of the Si/C ratio. For machine tool castings requiring HT300 grade (tensile strength ≥300 MPa for 30 mm diameter specimens), compositions with CE between 3.43% and 3.76% and Si/C between 0.55 and 0.89 achieved this without chromium addition. However, with chromium alloying, even compositions with lower Si/C (e.g., Group 12 and 15) met the strength criteria. This highlights the role of alloying in enhancing the performance of machine tool castings.

The relationship between CE and mechanical properties can be modeled mathematically. For instance, the tensile strength (\(R_m\)) as a function of CE and Si/C can be approximated by:

$$R_m = a \cdot CE + b \cdot (Si/C) + c$$

where \(a\), \(b\), and \(c\) are constants derived from regression analysis. Based on the data, I observed that for a given CE, increasing Si/C improves tensile strength by 10–30 MPa. Similarly, hardness (\(HB\)) follows a trend:

$$HB = d \cdot CE + e \cdot (Si/C) + f$$

with \(d\), \(e\), and \(f\) as constants. These relationships underscore the importance of optimizing both CE and Si/C for high-strength machine tool castings.

Section sensitivity is a critical factor for machine tool castings, as they often have varying wall thicknesses. The difference in mechanical properties between thin and thick sections (represented by 30 mm and 120 mm diameter specimens) indicates section sensitivity. Lower values of ΔRm (difference in tensile strength) and ΔHBW (difference in hardness) imply better uniformity. From the table, compositions with Si/C between 0.67 and 0.81 (e.g., Groups 2–6, 8–10, 12, 15, 17–18) showed ΔRm below 100 MPa and ΔHBW below 50 HBW, indicating reduced section sensitivity. This is advantageous for machine tool castings with complex geometries.

To quantify section sensitivity, I define a section sensitivity index (\(SSI\)) as:

$$SSI = \frac{R_{m,30} – R_{m,120}}{R_{m,30}} + \frac{HB_{30} – HB_{120}}{HB_{30}}$$

where \(R_{m,30}\) and \(R_{m,120}\) are tensile strengths for 30 mm and 120 mm specimens, respectively, and similarly for hardness. Lower \(SSI\) values denote better section uniformity. For example, Group 3 (with Cr) had an \(SSI\) of approximately 0.25, while Group 14 had an \(SSI\) of 0.45, confirming that higher Si/C and alloying reduce sensitivity.

Residual stress measurements from the stress frames are summarized below. The elongation percentage directly correlates with residual stress; lower percentages indicate lower stresses, which are desirable for stable machine tool castings.

Group No. CE (%) Si/C Cr (%) Initial Length \(L_1\) (mm) Length After Cutting \(L_2\) (mm) Elongation \(L_2 – L_1\) (mm) Elongation Percentage (%)
1 3.43 0.55 – 88.30 89.98 1.68 1.90
2 3.54 0.69 – 88.74 90.03 1.29 1.45
3 3.62 0.72 0.35 88.02 89.31 1.29 1.47
4 3.65 0.75 – 87.84 89.04 1.20 1.37
5 3.66 0.72 – 88.10 89.38 1.28 1.45
6 3.81 0.89 – 87.92 89.11 1.19 1.36
7 3.56 0.53 – 88.08 89.82 1.74 1.98
8 3.66 0.68 – 88.90 90.14 1.24 1.39
9 3.66 0.68 0.30 87.88 89.14 1.26 1.43
10 3.76 0.79 – 87.96 89.21 1.25 1.42
11 3.72 0.48 – 87.92 89.72 1.80 2.05
12 3.72 0.48 0.30 87.91 89.75 1.84 2.09
13 3.68 0.51 – 87.84 89.56 1.72 1.96
14 3.75 0.48 – 88.25 90.11 1.86 2.11
15 3.68 0.50 0.30 88.12 89.96 1.84 2.09
16 3.81 0.64 – 88.16 89.58 1.42 1.61
17 3.94 0.67 – 87.98 89.43 1.45 1.65
18 4.01 0.81 – 88.04 89.42 1.38 1.57

The data shows that compositions with Si/C ratios above 0.60 (e.g., Groups 2–6, 8–10, 16–18) have elongation percentages below 1.7%, while those with Si/C below 0.55 (e.g., Groups 7, 11–15) exceed 1.9%. This confirms that higher Si/C ratios effectively reduce residual stresses in machine tool castings. The residual stress (\(\sigma_r\)) can be estimated from the elongation percentage using the formula:

$$\sigma_r = k \cdot \frac{L_2 – L_1}{L_1}$$

where \(k\) is a material constant. For low-stress machine tool castings, targeting Si/C > 0.60 is beneficial.

Chill tendency, evaluated via triangular test blocks, is another key aspect for machine tool castings, as it affects machinability and surface integrity. The results for selected groups are tabulated below.

Group No. CE (%) Si/C Cr (%) Tensile Strength (MPa) White Depth Before Inoculation (mm) White Depth After Inoculation (mm)
5 3.66 0.72 – 315 10 3
7 3.56 0.53 – 300 25 15
8 3.66 0.68 – 330 12 8
12 3.72 0.48 0.30 310 30 10

Groups with Si/C > 0.60 (e.g., 5 and 8) exhibited lower white depths after inoculation (<10 mm) compared to those with lower Si/C (e.g., 7 and 12 with ≥10 mm). This indicates that higher Si/C ratios reduce chill tendency, which is favorable for the castability of machine tool castings. The chill depth (\(D_c\)) can be related to Si/C and CE by an empirical equation:

$$D_c = \alpha \cdot \exp(-\beta \cdot (Si/C)) + \gamma \cdot CE$$

where \(\alpha\), \(\beta\), and \(\gamma\) are constants. Minimizing \(D_c\) ensures better graphite formation and fewer casting defects.

Based on the experimental findings, I validated the optimized composition in actual production of machine tool bed castings. Two castings, designated V501091 and V501092, were produced with the following compositions:

Casting ID C (%) Si (%) Mn (%) P (%) S (%) Cr (%) CE (%) Si/C
V501091 3.02 1.68 0.92 0.042 0.076 – 3.58 0.56
V501092 2.96 2.03 0.98 0.046 0.082 0.30 3.64 0.68

Both castings were machine tool beds weighing 10,700 kg, with dimensions of 8,500 mm × 1,035 mm × 550 mm and wall thicknesses ranging from 35 mm to 130 mm. The pouring temperature was 1,370°C ± 10°C, with inoculation using 0.6% SiFe75. The castings were shaken out after 192 hours to allow stress relief. Mechanical tests on separately cast test bars showed that V501091 had a tensile strength of 309 MPa and hardness of 219 HBW, while V501092 achieved 348 MPa and 241 HBW. Metallography revealed primarily type A graphite and over 98% pearlite in both, but V501092 had finer structures due to chromium addition.

Deformation measurements on the bed guide rails after machining (without artificial aging before rough machining) demonstrated the superiority of the optimized composition. The deformation over time is summarized below.

Casting ID Composition Type Deformation After 1 Hour (mm) Deformation After 24 Hours (mm) Deformation After 30 Days (mm) Deformation After 3 Months (mm) Deformation After 6 Months (mm)
V501091 Standard 0.011 (concave) 0.013 (concave) 0.025 (concave) 0.048 (concave) 0.079 (concave)
V501092 Optimized Low-Stress 0.010 (concave) 0.011 (concave) 0.012 (concave) 0.012 (concave) 0.012 (concave)

V501092, with CE=3.64% and Si/C=0.68, exhibited minimal deformation (stable at 0.012 mm concave) over six months, whereas V501091 showed progressive deformation up to 0.079 mm. This confirms that the optimized composition reduces residual stresses and enhances dimensional stability in machine tool castings, eliminating the need for pre-machining aging and lowering production costs.

In conclusion, this study demonstrates that the mechanical properties, section sensitivity, residual stress, and chill tendency of HT300 gray iron castings are significantly influenced by the silicon-to-carbon ratio and alloying elements. For high-strength low-stress machine tool castings, I recommend a chemical composition with a carbon equivalent (CE) between 3.60% and 3.75% and a silicon-to-carbon ratio (Si/C) between 0.60 and 0.75. The addition of chromium up to 0.3% further enhances strength and stability. These parameters ensure tensile strengths above 300 MPa, uniform hardness, low residual stresses, and reduced deformation, meeting the rigorous demands of modern machine tool castings. The mathematical relationships and empirical data provided here offer a foundation for optimizing casting processes, contributing to the advancement of high-performance machine tool castings in the manufacturing industry.

Scroll to Top