Improving Fatigue Wear Resistance of Grey Iron Casting via Localized Laser Carburizing

In this study, I investigate the enhancement of fatigue wear resistance in grey iron casting through a novel laser carburizing technique. Grey iron casting, widely used in engineering applications such as bearings, gears, and rail contacts, offers advantages like low cost, excellent castability, and good wear resistance. However, its performance under cyclic contact stresses is often limited by the presence of flake graphite, which acts as inherent defects, leading to premature fatigue failure through mechanisms like pitting, spalling, and cracking. Traditional surface modification methods, including physical vapor deposition, chemical vapor deposition, thermal spraying, and plasma transferred arc welding, have been employed to address this issue. Yet, these approaches face limitations such as thin coating thickness, interfacial cracking risks due to material mismatch, and chemical discontinuities, which can exacerbate failure in high-stress environments. To overcome these challenges, I propose a localized laser carburizing process that integrates carbon into the surface of grey iron casting, aiming to homogenize the microstructure, eliminate graphite-based crack initiation sites, and enhance resistance to fatigue wear. This research focuses on optimizing the laser processing conditions by examining the effects of input energy density on the treated regions, comparing laser carburizing with laser remelting, and elucidating the underlying mechanisms through experimental analysis and finite element modeling. The findings demonstrate that laser carburizing significantly improves the fatigue wear resistance of grey iron casting compared to laser remelting, with the degree of improvement positively correlated with energy density. This work provides insights into the development of efficient surface engineering strategies for grey iron casting components subjected to rolling contact fatigue.

The base material used in this study is grey iron casting, conforming to the HT 150 grade according to relevant standards. The nominal chemical composition of the grey iron casting is summarized in Table 1. The microstructure of the as-received grey iron casting consists of flake graphite embedded in a matrix of pearlite and ferrite, with graphite widths approximately 4 μm. The matrix is predominantly pearlite (95%) with minor ferrite (5%), contributing to a microhardness of about 260 HV0.2, tensile strength of 135 MPa, and fracture strength of 90 MPa. For laser treatment, amorphous carbon powder with 98% purity is applied as a precursor for carburizing. The specimens are prepared by cutting blocks of dimensions 5 mm thickness, 15 mm width, and 120 mm length from cast slabs. Prior to laser processing, the surfaces are polished using progressively finer silicon carbide sandpaper to minimize the influence of machining marks. A sodium silicate binder is used to pre-place the carbon powder on the surface, preventing powder ejection during laser irradiation.

Table 1: Nominal chemical composition of the grey iron casting (wt%).
C Si Mn P S Fe
3.0–3.2 1.5–1.8 0.7–0.9 <0.15 <0.12 Bal.

The laser surface treatment is performed using a Nd:YAG laser system with a wavelength of 1.064 μm and maximum power of 300 W, under an argon shielding atmosphere to prevent oxidation. The laser parameters include a pulse duration of 5.0 ms, frequency of 9 Hz, and single-pulse energy of 5.37 J. By adjusting the focal length, different energy densities are achieved: 10.7 J/mm² at 10 mm焦距, 6.84 J/mm² at 12 mm焦距, and 4.75 J/mm² at 14 mm焦距. The processing conditions are designed to compare laser carburizing (LC) and laser remelting (LM), with details provided in Table 2. The treated regions, referred to as “units,” are fabricated as strips along the specimen length with a center-to-center spacing of 5 mm, using a traverse speed of 0.3 mm/s. For consistency, laser remelted samples and untreated parent material (PM) samples are also prepared for benchmarking.

Table 2: Laser processing parameters for the prepared samples.
Sample No. Laser Spot Diameter (mm) Pre-placed Carbon Layer Thickness (mm) Energy Density (J/mm²) Description
1 — — — Parent Material (PM)
2 0.8 0 10.7 Laser Remelting (LM)
3 0.8 0.2 10.7 Laser Carburizing (LC)
4 1.0 0 6.84 Laser Remelting (LM)
5 1.0 0.2 6.84 Laser Carburizing (LC)
6 1.2 0 4.75 Laser Remelting (LM)
7 1.2 0.2 4.75 Laser Carburizing (LC)

Following laser treatment, cross-sections of the units are prepared using standard metallographic techniques for microstructural analysis. Optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) are employed to examine the dimensions and morphology of the units. Phase identification is conducted via X-ray diffraction (XRD) with Cu Kα radiation, operated at 40 kV and 40 mA, with a scanning speed of 4°/min. Microhardness measurements are taken using a Vickers microhardness tester under a load of 0.2 kg and dwell time of 10 s. Tensile and compressive tests are performed on a material testing system to evaluate mechanical properties. Rolling contact fatigue (RCF) tests are carried out on a custom-built tester, employing SAE 46 mechanical oil for lubrication to establish elastohydrodynamic conditions. The test involves a rolling bearing with 10 rollers (made of GCr15 steel, hardness 63 HRC) applying a load of 80 N per roller, oscillating at a speed of 30 rpm, equivalent to a horizontal velocity of 7 cm/s. Mass loss is measured every 10 hours up to 70 hours using an electronic balance with 0.1 mg precision. The fatigue wear resistance is assessed based on mass loss (ML) and mass loss rate (MLR). Additionally, finite element analysis (FEA) is utilized to predict contact stress distributions on the sample surfaces under static loading conditions, assuming pure rolling contact with a friction coefficient of zero and using parameters listed in Table 3.

Table 3: Material parameters used in finite element analysis.
Material Elasticity Modulus (GPa) Poisson’s Ratio Density (g/cm³)
Parent Material (PM) 130 0.23 7.4
Unit Region 150 0.25 7.8

The laser carburizing process involves rapid heating and melting of the grey iron casting surface, followed by rapid solidification, leading to microstructural transformations. The cross-sectional profiles of the units approximate inverted parabolas, with dimensions summarized in Table 4. As the laser spot size increases at constant input energy, the energy density decreases, resulting in wider but shallower units with reduced area. Comparatively, laser carburizing units (LCUs) exhibit greater depth and area than laser remelting units (LMUs) under identical processing parameters, attributed to enhanced laser absorption due to the carbon layer. The effective heat input during laser processing can be described by:

$$ Q_{eff} = \frac{P}{V} $$

where \( P \) is laser power and \( V \) is traverse speed. However, accounting for absorption efficiency \( \eta \), the actual effective heat input becomes:

$$ Q_{eff}’ = \eta \frac{P}{V} $$

For grey iron casting, the absorption rate is approximately 20%, but with a carbon coating, it increases to about 90%, leading to higher temperature in the melt pool and deeper unit penetration. This enhanced absorption also limits heat diffusion laterally, explaining the narrower width of LCUs compared to LMUs.

Table 4: Geometrical dimensions of laser-treated units.
Sample No. Unit Width (mm) Unit Depth (mm) Unit Area (mm²)
2 (LMU) 1.26 0.84 0.71
3 (LCU) 1.03 1.10 0.76
4 (LMU) 1.43 0.24 0.23
5 (LCU) 1.25 0.50 0.42
6 (LMU) 1.52 0.10 0.10
7 (LCU) 1.37 0.15 0.14

XRD analysis reveals the phase composition of the treated units. The parent grey iron casting primarily consists of graphite (G) and ferrite (F). After laser treatment, new phases form, including martensite (M), retained austenite (Ar), and cementite (Fe3C). While both LCUs and LMUs show similar phases, LCUs exhibit broader diffraction peaks, indicating finer grain size and higher lattice strain due to enhanced carbon dissolution and rapid cooling. Quantitative analysis of peak broadening for the (110) plane is summarized in Table 5, confirming grain refinement in laser carburizing of grey iron casting.

Table 5: XRD peak information for the (110) lattice plane in treated units.
Sample No. 2θ (°) FWHM (°)
2 (LMU) 44.660 0.286
3 (LCU) 44.600 0.315
4 (LMU) 44.684 0.307
5 (LCU) 44.599 0.326
6 (LMU) 44.634 0.315
7 (LCU) 44.626 0.338

Microstructural observations show that both LCUs and LMUs are free of flake graphite, as graphite is either ablated or dissolved during melting. In LMUs, the microstructure is non-uniform, with retained ferrite and varying grain sizes, due to limited carbon availability from the base grey iron casting. In contrast, LCUs display a more homogeneous microstructure with refined grains, increased carbide content, and a higher percentage of ledeburite (eutectic mixture of cementite and austenite/martensite). Specifically, LCUs contain 60–70% ledeburite, compared to 40–45% in LMUs, owing to additional carbon from the coating. The microstructure evolves with energy density: higher energy densities promote finer structures and more continuous carbide networks, while lower energy densities lead to coarser grains and reduced carbide formation. This is critical for the fatigue wear resistance of grey iron casting, as refined microstructures impede crack propagation. The microhardness of the units correlates positively with energy density, and LCUs consistently exhibit higher hardness than LMUs under the same conditions, as shown in Table 6. This enhancement is attributed to grain refinement, solid solution strengthening, and increased hard phase content in the laser-carburized grey iron casting.

Table 6: Microhardness of laser-treated units at different energy densities.
Sample No. Energy Density (J/mm²) Microhardness (HV0.2)
2 (LMU) 10.7 680
3 (LCU) 10.7 750
4 (LMU) 6.84 520
5 (LCU) 6.84 600
6 (LMU) 4.75 400
7 (LCU) 4.75 450

The fatigue wear resistance of grey iron casting is evaluated through rolling contact fatigue tests. The mass loss rate over time for all samples follows a similar trend: an initial run-in period with increasing wear rate, followed by a steady-state regime. The transition to steady-state occurs earlier for laser-treated samples, indicating delayed crack initiation. The steady-state mass loss rates and total mass loss after 70 hours are presented in Table 7. Sample 3 (LCU at 10.7 J/mm²) shows the lowest mass loss rate of 2 mg/10 h, while the parent grey iron casting (Sample 1) exhibits the highest rate of 2.65 mg/10 h. Overall, laser carburizing improves fatigue wear resistance more effectively than laser remelting, and the improvement escalates with increasing energy density. For instance, at 10.7 J/mm², the LCU reduces mass loss by approximately 25% compared to the LMU. This underscores the efficacy of laser carburizing in enhancing the durability of grey iron casting under cyclic loading.

Table 7: Fatigue wear test results for grey iron casting samples.
Sample No. Treatment Steady-State MLR (mg/10 h) Total ML after 70 h (mg)
1 PM 2.65 18.55
2 LM 2.27 15.89
3 LC 2.00 14.00
4 LM 2.40 16.80
5 LC 2.27 15.89
6 LM 2.50 17.50
7 LC 2.45 17.15

To understand the mechanisms behind fatigue wear improvement, I analyze crack initiation and propagation in grey iron casting. In the parent material, flake graphite acts as pre-existing cracks, where stress concentrations at graphite tips facilitate crack initiation under cyclic stresses. These cracks can coalesce, forming larger cracks that lead to spalling and delamination. Laser treatment eliminates graphite, thereby removing crack initiation sites. Additionally, the refined microstructure in treated units, especially in laser-carburized grey iron casting, increases the resistance to crack propagation by deflecting cracks and requiring more energy for growth. The fatigue life related to ratcheting failure can be expressed as:

$$ N_f = \frac{\epsilon_c}{\Delta \epsilon_r} $$

where \( \epsilon_c \) is the critical strain for failure and \( \Delta \epsilon_r \) is the equivalent ratcheting plastic strain per cycle, given by:

$$ \Delta \epsilon_r = \sqrt{(\Delta \epsilon)^2 + \left(\frac{\Delta \gamma}{\sqrt{3}}\right)^2 } $$

Here, \( \Delta \epsilon \) and \( \Delta \gamma \) represent the axial and shear ratcheting strains per cycle, respectively. The improved resistance to deformation in laser-carburized grey iron casting reduces \( \Delta \epsilon_r \), thereby extending \( N_f \). Mechanical testing confirms that laser carburizing enhances both tensile and compressive properties compared to laser remelting and the parent material, as illustrated in Figure 1 for stress-strain curves. For example, at an energy density of 10.7 J/mm², the tensile strength of LCU increases by 30% over LMU, and ductility also improves. This synergy of higher strength and toughness contributes to better fatigue wear performance in grey iron casting.

Finite element analysis provides insights into contact stress distributions on the sample surfaces. Under static loading of 8 N, the parent grey iron casting exhibits maximum contact stresses at the edges of roller contact, while in laser-treated samples, peak stresses are concentrated within the unit regions. The subsurface shear stress also peaks in the units, indicating that these regions bear the brunt of cyclic loading. The stress profile along the surface shows a saddle-shaped distribution, with treated samples experiencing lower stresses in the matrix areas compared to the parent material. This stress redistribution reduces the load on the matrix, delaying fatigue damage. The maximum stress in units is higher due to their elevated elastic modulus, but the refined microstructure and absence of graphite mitigate crack formation. Consequently, units exhibit only minor pitting, whereas the matrix and parent material suffer severe spalling. This demonstrates how laser carburizing optimizes stress accommodation in grey iron casting, enhancing overall fatigue resistance.

The improvement in fatigue wear resistance of grey iron casting through laser carburizing can be attributed to multiple synergistic mechanisms. First, the dissolution of flake graphite eliminates inherent crack initiation sites, which are critical weak points in grey iron casting. Second, the rapid solidification leads to grain refinement, increasing the hardness and strength of the surface layer. Third, the introduction of excess carbon promotes the formation of hard carbides and a homogeneous distribution of ledeburite, which act as barriers to crack propagation. Fourth, the enhanced microstructure improves resistance to plastic deformation, reducing ratcheting strain accumulation under cyclic loads. These factors collectively delay the onset of fatigue cracks and slow their growth, thereby extending the service life of grey iron casting components. Furthermore, the laser carburizing process offers practical advantages, such as localized treatment that minimizes energy consumption and avoids coating delamination issues associated with traditional methods. By tailoring the energy density, the depth and properties of the carburized layer can be controlled, making it adaptable for various applications of grey iron casting in demanding environments.

In conclusion, this study demonstrates that localized laser carburizing is a highly effective method for improving the fatigue wear resistance of grey iron casting. Compared to laser remelting, laser carburizing produces more uniform and refined microstructures with higher carbide content, leading to superior mechanical properties and enhanced resistance to crack initiation and propagation. The degree of improvement is positively correlated with input energy density, with higher densities yielding better performance. Finite element analysis confirms that the treated units redistribute contact stresses, reducing loads on the matrix and mitigating fatigue damage. The mechanisms involve the elimination of graphite flaws, grain refinement, and increased hard phase formation, all contributing to extended fatigue life. These findings provide a foundation for optimizing laser surface engineering techniques for grey iron casting, offering a viable solution to enhance durability in rolling contact applications. Future work could explore the effects of varying carbon sources or laser parameters on the microstructure and performance of grey iron casting, as well as long-term fatigue behavior under different lubrication conditions.

Scroll to Top