I have reviewed the group standard titled “Ductile Iron Castings of Worm Gear Shaft for Photovoltaic Solar Energy” (T/CFA 020101211-2024), and I would like to present a detailed interpretation of its technical content, drafting process, and practical significance. This standard addresses a critical component in solar tracking systems: the worm gear shaft. Because the worm gear shaft supports and transmits torque from a worm gear reducer to solar panel working units, it operates under harsh conditions. Therefore, the material must provide excellent strength, toughness, wear resistance, contact fatigue resistance, and low-temperature impact toughness. Conventional ductile iron casting standards, both domestic and international, no longer fully satisfy these demands. Austempered ductile iron (ADI) has emerged as an ideal material for such worm gear shafts because of its unique combination of high strength, high toughness, and high wear resistance. However, before this standard, no dedicated standard existed for photovoltaic solar worm gear shafts made of austempered ductile iron. The new group standard fills this technical gap and provides a basis for material selection and commercial transactions between suppliers and buyers.
In my interpretation, the standard is not merely a specification for a single part. It represents a successful innovation in using austempered ductile iron casting for renewable energy equipment. The standard was developed under the China Foundry Association’s 2023 group standard revision plan. The drafting group was established in February 2023. The main drafting organization visited production, design, and application units to understand the domestic and international application status of ductile iron casting for photovoltaic solar worm gear shafts. Technical data and application information were collected to lay a foundation for the standard. After multiple discussions and demonstrations, a solicitation for comments was issued on December 26, 2023, and the comment period ended on January 12, 2024. All comments were summarized and addressed item by item. A draft for review, along with the drafting explanation and comment summary, was submitted on May 18, 2024. A standard review meeting was held on July 12, 2024, in Rizhao, Shandong. The review experts raised 12 comments, all of which were adopted. The draft for approval, together with the drafting explanation and comment summary, was submitted on August 8, 2024. The China Foundry Association officially released the standard on August 28, 2024, and it became effective on November 27, 2024.
The scope of this standard covers terms and definitions, technical requirements, test methods, inspection rules, marking, quality certificates, as well as rust prevention, packaging, storage, and transportation. It applies to sand-cast and austempered ductile iron casting for worm gear shafts. Other casting processes used to produce austempered worm gear shaft ductile iron casting may refer to this standard. The normative references include documents that are either dated or undated. For dated references, only the edition corresponding to that date applies. For undated references, the latest edition, including all amendments, applies. This approach ensures that the standard remains current while maintaining clarity for specific editions.
The standard establishes three material grades for photovoltaic solar worm gear shaft ductile iron casting: QTD1050-8L, QTD1200-4L, and QTD1400-2L. Each grade designation consists of four parts: the austempered ductile iron identifier, the room-temperature tensile strength value, the percentage elongation after fracture, and the low-temperature impact absorption energy. I can express the general designation formula as follows:
$$ \text{QTD} \, R_m – A \, L $$
Here, QTD indicates austempered ductile iron, \(R_m\) is the minimum tensile strength in MPa, \(A\) is the minimum elongation in percent, and \(L\) indicates low-temperature impact performance. For example, QTD1050-8L means a minimum tensile strength of 1050 MPa, a minimum elongation of 8%, and guaranteed low-temperature impact toughness. The three grades provide options for different wall thicknesses and service conditions. The chemical composition is given as a reference range, which I summarize in Table 1.
| Element | C | Si | Mn | P | S | Cu | Sn | Cr | Mg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Range | 3.0–3.9 | 2.2–2.7 | ≤ 0.4 | ≤ 0.04 | ≤ 0.02 | ≤ 0.8 | ≤ 0.02 | ≤ 0.1 | 0.03–0.055 |
In my analysis, the chemical composition is carefully balanced to promote graphitization, spheroidization, and austempering response. Carbon and silicon control the carbon equivalent, which affects fluidity and graphitization. Magnesium is the spheroidizing element, and its residual range ensures a high nodularity. Copper and tin are optional alloying elements that stabilize austenite and increase hardenability during austempering. Manganese is kept low to avoid segregation and carbide formation. Phosphorus and sulfur are restricted because they form brittle phases and reduce toughness. For a ductile iron casting intended for a worm gear shaft, these limits are essential to achieve the required combination of strength, ductility, and fatigue resistance.

The mechanical properties specified for single cast or attached cast samples are summarized in Table 2. I note that the standard recommends using the room-temperature properties and low-temperature impact properties of the casting body as the acceptance basis, but the exact location and requirements for body testing should be agreed upon by the supplier and buyer. This flexibility is important because the properties of a ductile iron casting can vary with wall thickness and location.
| Material grade | Wall thickness \(t\) / mm | Tensile strength \(R_m\) / MPa | Yield strength \(R_{p0.2}\) / MPa | Elongation \(A\) / % | Brinell hardness HBW | Impact absorption energy / J | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 °C ± 5 °C | −20 °C ± 2 °C | −40 °C ± 2 °C | ||||||
| QTD1050-8L | \(t \le 30\) | ≥ 1050 | ≥ 750 | ≥ 8 | 310–380 | ≥ 80 | ≥ 45 | ≥ 35 |
| \(30 < t \le 60\) | ≥ 1000 | ≥ 750 | ≥ 5 | |||||
| QTD1200-4L | \(t \le 30\) | ≥ 1200 | ≥ 900 | ≥ 4 | 350–430 | ≥ 60 | ≥ 35 | ≥ 25 |
| \(30 < t \le 60\) | ≥ 1170 | ≥ 900 | ≥ 3 | |||||
| QTD1400-2L | \(t \le 30\) | ≥ 1400 | ≥ 1100 | ≥ 2 | 380–480 | ≥ 35 | ≥ 20 | ≥ 15 |
| \(30 < t \le 60\) | ≥ 1300 | ≥ 1100 | ≥ 2 | |||||
I would like to emphasize that the impact absorption energy is measured using unnotched specimens. This is a notable detail because notched impact tests can be more sensitive to stress concentrations, but for austempered ductile iron casting used in worm gear shafts, unnotched specimens provide a practical assessment of toughness under low-temperature service. The required impact energies at −20 °C and −40 °C are particularly important for photovoltaic installations in cold climates. The standard therefore sets three low-temperature grades, which I summarize in terms of minimum impact energy in Table 3.
| Grade | \(23 \, ^\circ\text{C}\) / J | \(-20 \, ^\circ\text{C}\) / J | \(-40 \, ^\circ\text{C}\) / J |
|---|---|---|---|
| QTD1050-8L | ≥ 80 | ≥ 45 | ≥ 35 |
| QTD1200-4L | ≥ 60 | ≥ 35 | ≥ 25 |
| QTD1400-2L | ≥ 35 | ≥ 20 | ≥ 15 |
The metallographic requirements are also critical for a reliable ductile iron casting. Graphite must be predominantly spheroidal, with a nodularity of not less than 90%. The graphite particle count must be not less than 120 per square millimeter. The matrix should consist of acicular ferrite and carbon-rich austenite. Carbides plus phosphide eutectic must not exceed 1%. I can express these requirements as follows:
$$ N_s \ge 90\% $$
$$ N_g \ge 120 \, \text{mm}^{-2} $$
$$ \phi_{\text{carbide}} + \phi_{\text{phosphide}} \le 1\% $$
These metallographic parameters directly influence fatigue strength and fatigue life. In general, for the same tensile strength and ductility, a higher nodularity and a finer graphite particle count lead to better fatigue performance. Therefore, the standard encourages a high nodularity and a fine graphite distribution. Based on current production technology, a nodularity of at least 90% and a graphite count of 120 to 300 per square millimeter are appropriate and achievable by advanced foundries. I consider this requirement to be both realistic and forward-looking for ductile iron casting producers.
Internal defects are controlled according to Table 4. The standard refers to ASTM E446-15 for defect classification and severity levels. Gas holes, sand inclusions, shrinkage cavities, and shrinkage porosity are all limited to level 2 or better. This ensures that the ductile iron casting has adequate internal soundness for a load-bearing worm gear shaft.
| Defect category | Defect name | Allowed severity level |
|---|---|---|
| A | Gas holes | ≤ level 2 |
| B | Sand inclusions | ≤ level 2 |
| C | Shrinkage cavities | ≤ level 2 |
| D | Shrinkage porosity | ≤ level 2 |
Regarding process control, the standard specifies inspection methods and sampling procedures. The location for attached cast samples on the casting should be agreed upon by the supplier and buyer. The location must not affect the structural function, appearance quality, or sample density. For castings requiring heat treatment, attached samples should be cut from the casting after heat treatment. Inspection is divided into factory inspection and type inspection. Factory inspection includes mechanical properties, metallographic structure, geometric shape and dimensional tolerances, weight deviation, and surface quality. Special requirements can be agreed upon by both parties. Type inspection includes all items such as metallography, mechanical properties, and low-temperature impact performance. Type inspection is required when low-temperature impact absorption energy is used as the acceptance basis, or when one of the following conditions occurs: new product finalization and qualification; changes in key processes, equipment, or site; or a significant difference between factory inspection results and the previous type inspection results.
The standard is the first of its kind. There are no similar standards domestically or internationally. Some clauses refer to GB/T 24733-2023, “Austempered Ductile Iron Castings.” The standard adds three low-temperature austempered ductile iron grades to the existing national and international standards, namely QTD1050-8L, QTD1200-4L, and QTD1400-2L. It is consistent with GB/T 24733-2023, ISO 17804:2020, ASTM A897M-2016, and EN 1564-2016. I have prepared a comparison table to illustrate the relationship between this group standard and the referenced standards.
| Standard | Scope | Low-temperature grades added | Key contribution of the group standard |
|---|---|---|---|
| T/CFA 020101211-2024 | Photovoltaic solar worm gear shaft ductile iron casting | QTD1050-8L, QTD1200-4L, QTD1400-2L | Specific to solar tracking worm gear shafts; includes low-temperature impact requirements |
| GB/T 24733-2023 | Austempered ductile iron castings | Not specifically for photovoltaic worm gear shafts | General ADI standard; the group standard refers to it |
| ISO 17804:2020 | Austempered ductile iron – classification | Limited low-temperature designations | International classification; the group standard adds new grades |
| ASTM A897M-2016 | Standard specification for austempered ductile iron castings | Not tailored to solar worm gear shafts | American standard; the group standard aligns with its framework |
| EN 1564-2016 | Founding – austempered ductile cast irons | European grades | European standard; the group standard harmonizes with it |
The standard complies with relevant national laws and regulations. According to the Standardization Law of the People’s Republic of China, it is scientific, reasonable, advanced, and applicable. It helps improve the technical level and economic benefits of production enterprises, protects consumer interests, promotes rational use of national resources, supports green development, and facilitates international economic and technical cooperation and foreign trade. It meets the requirements of leading concepts, advanced technology, and economic rationality. It is legal, practical, normative, and coordinated. It is consistent with current laws, regulations, rules, and related standards.
I find the experimental verification section particularly important. The mechanical property data for single cast and attached cast samples were verified experimentally and estimated from production statistics. The test results show that the requirements in the standard are feasible. Because castings differ in size, structure, and sampling location, the mechanical properties of body samples can vary considerably. Therefore, the mechanical properties of body samples should be determined through negotiation with the user. The standard provides reference requirements for body samples. The mechanical property data of single cast and attached cast samples were analyzed by a railway vehicle research institute. The results correspond to the QTD1400-2L grade for photovoltaic solar worm gear shaft ductile iron casting. The worm gear shaft wall thickness is 18 mm, and its main wall thickness is in the range \(12.5 < t \le 30\). Three groups of single cast sample tests for mechanical properties and metallographic structure correspond to the main wall thickness range of QTD1400-2L. These data provide confidence that the standard can be applied in actual production.
The standard also specifies that the metallographic structure of the ductile iron casting should be predominantly spheroidal graphite, with a nodularity of not less than 90% or better than level 2, and a graphite particle count of not less than 120 per square millimeter. In general, at the same tensile strength and plasticity, a higher nodularity and finer graphite particles lead to better fatigue strength or fatigue life. Therefore, a high nodularity and fine graphite particles are desirable for ductile iron casting. Given the current state of ductile iron production technology, a nodularity of not less than 90% and a graphite nodule count of 120 to 300 per square millimeter are suitable and achievable by advanced domestic foundries. The photovoltaic solar worm gear shaft ductile iron casting has been batch-used in solar photovoltaic automatic tracking system worm gear reducers and supporting photovoltaic solar power hosts by several companies. The relevant content of the standard has been applied and produced in key user facilities. The content is close to production practice and has good guidance and standardization effects. Production according to these indicators can meet customer technical requirements.
In terms of advancement, the standard is consistent with GB/T 26655-2011 and the international standards ISO 17804:2020, ASTM A897M-2016, and EN 1564-2016. It adds three new low-temperature austempered ductile iron grades on the basis of national and international standards. It is more suitable for the actual needs of the photovoltaic solar equipment parts industry and the foundry industry, and it is more operable. The formulation of this standard provides technical guidance for enterprise production, quality inspection, and import and export trade of castings. With the release of the standard, it will undoubtedly promote industrial upgrading and development, promote product upgrading, improve production processes, and improve product quality. It will strongly promote local industrial upgrading and industrialization. The standard content is scientific and reasonable, highly operable, innovative in the photovoltaic solar equipment manufacturing industry and foundry industry, fills the gap in domestic and international industry standards, and reaches the international advanced level.
The characteristics of the standard can be summarized as follows. First, it follows the requirements of ISO 9000 and highlights the needs of the buyer, reflecting a customer-oriented process. Second, it emphasizes negotiation rules between the supplier and buyer. Third, it highlights experimental verification. I have organized these characteristics in Table 6.
| Characteristic | Description | Benefit for ductile iron casting |
|---|---|---|
| Customer-oriented process | Follows ISO 9000 requirements and emphasizes buyer needs | Ensures that the ductile iron casting meets actual service demands |
| Negotiation principle | Requires agreement between supplier and buyer on sampling, body properties, and special requirements | Provides flexibility for different casting geometries and applications |
| Experimental verification | Based on production statistics and independent testing | Confirms that the specified properties are achievable |
In conclusion, the group standard “Ductile Iron Castings of Worm Gear Shaft for Photovoltaic Solar Energy” is a comprehensive document. I believe it will promote the application of new materials, new processes, and new technologies, and standardize management. It is suitable as a recommended standard. When customers have special requirements, those requirements should be satisfied. The standard serves as a basis for acceptance of worm gear shafts, middle shafts, top plates, and other castings by both suppliers and buyers. It is also suitable for austempered ductile iron casting production enterprises as a technical standard for guidance. By providing clear material grades, chemical composition ranges, mechanical properties, metallographic requirements, internal defect limits, and inspection rules, the standard enables reliable production and application of ductile iron casting in photovoltaic solar tracking systems. I am confident that this standard will contribute to the healthy and sustainable development of the solar photovoltaic power generation industry.
For further technical insight, I can express the relationship between wall thickness and minimum tensile strength as a step function. For each grade, the standard defines two thickness ranges. For QTD1050-8L, the minimum tensile strength is 1050 MPa for \(t \le 30\) mm and 1000 MPa for \(30 < t \le 60\) mm. For QTD1200-4L, the values are 1200 MPa and 1170 MPa, respectively. For QTD1400-2L, the values are 1400 MPa and 1300 MPa. This can be written as a piecewise function:
$$ R_m^{\min}(t) = \begin{cases} 1050, & t \le 30 \\ 1000, & 30 < t \le 60 \end{cases} \quad \text{for QTD1050-8L} $$
$$ R_m^{\min}(t) = \begin{cases} 1200, & t \le 30 \\ 1170, & 30 < t \le 60 \end{cases} \quad \text{for QTD1200-4L} $$
$$ R_m^{\min}(t) = \begin{cases} 1400, & t \le 30 \\ 1300, & 30 < t \le 60 \end{cases} \quad \text{for QTD1400-2L} $$
Similarly, the yield strength requirements can be expressed. For QTD1050-8L, the minimum yield strength is 750 MPa for both thickness ranges. For QTD1200-4L, it is 900 MPa for both ranges. For QTD1400-2L, it is 1100 MPa for both ranges. The elongation requirements decrease with increasing strength grade and with increasing wall thickness. For QTD1050-8L, the minimum elongation is 8% for \(t \le 30\) mm and 5% for \(30 < t \le 60\) mm. For QTD1200-4L, it is 4% and 3%, respectively. For QTD1400-2L, it is 2% for both ranges. These relationships highlight the trade-off between strength and ductility in austempered ductile iron casting.
The hardness ranges also reflect the strength grades. QTD1050-8L has a Brinell hardness of 310–380 HBW, QTD1200-4L has 350–430 HBW, and QTD1400-2L has 380–480 HBW. I can approximate the relationship between tensile strength and hardness using a common empirical formula for ductile iron:
$$ R_m \approx 3.3 \times \text{HBW} $$
For example, for QTD1400-2L with a tensile strength of 1400 MPa, the estimated hardness would be about 424 HBW, which falls within the specified range of 380–480 HBW. For QTD1050-8L with 1050 MPa, the estimated hardness is about 318 HBW, which is within 310–380 HBW. This consistency supports the internal coherence of the standard. However, actual hardness depends on matrix structure, alloying, and austempering parameters, so the empirical formula should be used only as a rough guide.
The low-temperature impact requirements are a distinctive feature of this standard. The impact energy values decrease as the test temperature decreases and as the strength grade increases. For QTD1050-8L, the minimum impact energy is 80 J at 23 °C, 45 J at −20 °C, and 35 J at −40 °C. For QTD1200-4L, the values are 60 J, 35 J, and 25 J. For QTD1400-2L, the values are 35 J, 20 J, and 15 J. These requirements ensure that the ductile iron casting can withstand low-temperature service conditions without brittle fracture. I can define a temperature-dependent impact energy requirement as a set of discrete values. In practice, the supplier and buyer may agree on additional testing temperatures if the application requires it.
The standard also addresses the importance of sample location. For attached cast samples, the location must not affect the structural function or appearance of the casting. This is particularly important for a worm gear shaft, where the gear teeth and bearing surfaces are critical. The sample should be representative of the casting body but should not compromise the integrity of the final part. After heat treatment, the attached sample should be cut from the casting. This ensures that the sample experiences the same austempering treatment as the casting. For single cast samples, the standard provides a separate set of mechanical properties. However, the standard recommends using body samples for acceptance when possible, because they better reflect the actual properties of the ductile iron casting.
The inspection rules are designed to ensure consistent quality. Factory inspection includes mechanical properties, metallographic structure, geometric dimensions, weight deviation, and surface quality. Type inspection includes all items, including low-temperature impact performance. Type inspection is required when low-temperature impact energy is used as the acceptance basis or when there are significant changes in production. This tiered approach allows for routine quality control while ensuring that critical applications receive full verification. I consider this to be a practical and efficient framework for ductile iron casting production.
The standard also references ASTM E446-15 for internal defect evaluation. This reference ensures that the defect classification is consistent with international practice. The allowed severity levels of 2 or better for gas holes, sand inclusions, shrinkage cavities, and shrinkage porosity are reasonable for a load-bearing worm gear shaft. Higher levels of these defects could reduce fatigue strength and lead to premature failure. Therefore, the internal quality requirements are aligned with the demanding service conditions of photovoltaic solar tracking systems.
In my view, the standard’s most significant contribution is the introduction of three low-temperature grades specifically for photovoltaic solar worm gear shafts. These grades extend the existing family of austempered ductile iron casting standards. By specifying low-temperature impact energy at −20 °C and −40 °C, the standard enables reliable material selection for solar installations in cold climates. This is important because solar tracking systems are often installed in regions with significant seasonal temperature variations. The standard therefore supports the global expansion of photovoltaic power generation.
I also appreciate the standard’s emphasis on negotiation between supplier and buyer. Because worm gear shafts can have different sizes, wall thicknesses, and service conditions, a rigid specification for body properties might be impractical. The standard therefore allows the supplier and buyer to agree on the exact location and requirements for body testing. This flexibility is balanced by clear requirements for single cast and attached cast samples, which provide a baseline for material qualification. The combination of mandatory baseline properties and negotiable body properties makes the standard both rigorous and adaptable.
The drafting process was thorough and inclusive. The drafting group visited production, design, and application units. They collected domestic and international technical data. They solicited comments from a wide range of stakeholders. The review meeting adopted all 12 comments raised by experts. This inclusive process helped ensure that the standard reflects the needs of the industry. I believe that this collaborative approach contributed to the standard’s high quality and practical relevance.
The standard is also consistent with the principles of green development. By enabling the production of durable, high-performance worm gear shafts, the standard helps extend the service life of solar tracking systems. Longer service life means fewer replacements and less resource consumption. In addition, the use of austempered ductile iron casting can reduce the need for more expensive alloy steels or forgings. This can lower production costs and improve the competitiveness of solar power. Therefore, the standard supports both economic and environmental sustainability.
For a more detailed summary of the inspection and testing plan, I have prepared Table 7. This table organizes the inspection items, methods, and frequency as described in the standard.
| Inspection item | Test method | Factory inspection | Type inspection | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mechanical properties | Tensile test on single cast or attached cast samples | Required | Required | Body properties may be agreed upon |
| Metallographic structure | Optical microscopy for nodularity, graphite count, matrix | Required | Required | Nodularity ≥ 90%, graphite count ≥ 120 mm\(^{-2}\) |
| Low-temperature impact | Unnotched impact test at 23 °C, −20 °C, −40 °C | As agreed | Required | Required when used as acceptance basis |
| Geometric dimensions | Measuring tools or gauges | Required | Required | According to drawing |
| Weight deviation | Weighing | Required | Required | According to agreed tolerance |
| Surface quality | Visual inspection | Required | Required | No harmful defects |
| Internal defects | Radiography or ultrasonic testing | As agreed | As agreed | ASTM E446-15, level ≤ 2 |
I would like to add a note on the mathematical representation of the grade designation. The general formula can be expanded to include the low-temperature impact energy symbol \(L\). However, the standard uses \(L\) as a suffix rather than a numerical value. The numerical value after the dash is the minimum elongation. For example, in QTD1050-8L, the number 8 indicates 8% elongation. The letter L indicates low-temperature impact performance. The tensile strength is indicated by the number 1050. Therefore, the full designation can be parsed as:
$$ \text{QTD} \, \underbrace{1050}_{\text{tensile strength}} – \underbrace{8}_{\text{elongation}} \underbrace{L}_{\text{low-temperature}} $$
This designation system is concise and informative. It allows engineers and buyers to quickly identify the key properties of the ductile iron casting. I find this to be a practical feature of the standard.
The standard also specifies that the graphite particle count should be 120 to 300 per square millimeter. This upper limit is not explicitly stated in the clause as a maximum, but the explanatory text suggests that 120 to 300 is suitable. In my interpretation, the lower limit of 120 is mandatory, while the upper limit of 300 is a recommended target. A higher graphite count generally improves fatigue resistance, but excessively high counts may be difficult to achieve consistently in thick sections. Therefore, the range of 120 to 300 provides a practical window for production.
The matrix structure of acicular ferrite plus carbon-rich austenite is characteristic of austempered ductile iron. This structure is often called ausferrite. The carbon-rich austenite provides toughness, while the acicular ferrite provides strength. The ratio of these phases can be controlled by austempering temperature and time. Lower austempering temperatures produce finer acicular ferrite and higher strength, but lower ductility. Higher austempering temperatures produce coarser structures and higher ductility, but lower strength. The three grades in the standard correspond to different austempering conditions and alloy compositions. I can represent the austempering process schematically as a heat treatment sequence:
$$ \text{Austenitize} \rightarrow \text{Quench to austempering temperature} \rightarrow \text{Hold} \rightarrow \text{Cool to room temperature} $$
The austenitizing temperature is typically in the range of 850–950 °C. The austempering temperature is typically in the range of 250–400 °C. The holding time depends on section size and alloy content. The standard does not prescribe exact heat treatment parameters because these are proprietary and depend on the foundry’s equipment and practice. Instead, the standard specifies the final properties that must be achieved. This performance-based approach allows foundries to optimize their own processes while ensuring that the ductile iron casting meets the required service performance.
In conclusion, I believe that the group standard T/CFA 020101211-2024 provides a comprehensive and practical framework for the production and acceptance of ductile iron casting for photovoltaic solar worm gear shafts. It fills a significant gap in existing standards by introducing three low-temperature austempered ductile iron grades. It specifies chemical composition, mechanical properties, metallographic requirements, internal defect limits, and inspection rules. It emphasizes customer orientation, supplier-buyer negotiation, and experimental verification. It is consistent with national and international standards and reaches an advanced level. I am confident that this standard will support the continued growth of the photovoltaic solar industry by enabling reliable, high-performance worm gear shafts made of ductile iron casting.
